This thread is archived
9,551 Views 29 Replies Last post: Feb 22, 2010 1:32 PM by LauraFOTF RSS 1 2 Previous Next
FocusMember Community Member 1 posts since
Apr 14, 2009
Currently Being Moderated

Apr 14, 2009 5:22 PM

Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

My daughter is 15 and she has never given me a reason not to trust her, but recently she has fallen head over heels over a boy at her school.  He is a senior and she is a freshman.  This does concern me even though I know his parents and he is going to be leaving on scholarship to college after this year.  I have recently found myself reading her texts on her phone when she is unaware, mostly to find out if I am getting the whole scoop about this young man.  What I found to my dismay is that she is using language (or at least on one text replying to similar language) that broke my heart.  I feel like she is trying to be "cool".  Now, any suggestions on how to bring this up to her without revealing that I have "gotten into her business" by looking on her phone.  Maybe she should know that her phone is not a private space and she should consider that when using it.  I don't know.  I am confused.  My daughter and I have always been very close and I want her to be able to trust me.  She has always been a child that when she realizes she's done wrong is ready to repent.  Any suggestions?

Tags: teens
genandedd4god Community Member 8 posts since
Apr 3, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
1. Apr 15, 2009 7:39 AM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

MY DAUGHTER HAD TEXTING And she is a few years younger than your daughter and she felt so invaded when her father read her texts one time i told her since she cant be trusted i would have to read her things i plopped down to read her locker mail (thats letters from jr. high kids to jr. high kids they call it locker mail,) anyway it made me feel like i was breaking a house rule because she lost trust due something that happened at her dads house. what we do is we talk about what if situations and sometimes we as parents role situations like friends that talk dirty to be cool thenwe talk about why it is kids do those things i would not bust yourself about reading her texts because if you have a close relationship with her  your going to need that trust that you all have and that closeness to deal with much more serious issues if the only thing you have to worry about right now is a dirty mouth be grateful you have done such a good job one thing that i hear constantly is mom they are so mean they have such dirty mouths this is coming from my sixth grader. try to be on their planet  long enough to understand or remember what it was like. i hear pick and choose your fights or battles wisely i hear that one from olderparents well god bless you all and pray pray pray

phred Community Member 10 posts since
Mar 26, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
2. Apr 15, 2009 9:21 AM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?
From a man's perspective it doesn't matter how nice the boy is; take her age in years, subtract seven and then double. That's the maximum age of the boy she's allowed to date. (The formula falls apart if she's younger than 14 but that's a good thing.)
Yes, it is unfair and prying and destructive to your relationship with your daughter to unexpectedly start reading her text messages but you should be reading them. So, once you've told her that she can't see this boy until the formula says so tell her that you will be monitoring all of her electronic communication from this point forward. Let her know that since she may have been expecting that the previous communication was private you will allow her to keep it so but from now on the rules are different. And don't allow her to get you to admit that you snooped. If she asks “Did you read my messages?” reply with “Why, is there something for me to see? If there is then you had better delete it.”
lad5939 Community Member 2 posts since
Mar 24, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
3. Apr 15, 2009 10:24 AM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I TO KNOW HOW IT FEELS TO READ YOUR DAUGTER'S TEXT.  I NEVER HAD A REASON NOT TO TRUST MY DAUGHTER.  SHE SOUNDS SO SIMILAR TO YOUR DAUGHTER ACCEPT SHE IS NOW 17.  SHE STARTED ACTING DIFFERENT, LIKE SHE WAS HIDING SOMETHING. AND I STARTED INVESTIGATING, BUT I COULD NEVER GET HER PHONE TO READ HER TEXT.  SO, I MANAGED TO GET INTO HER MY SPACE ACCOUNT THAT WAS WHEN I FOUND OUT SHE WAS BACK WITH HER EX-BOYFRIEND.  SHE HAD TOLD ME SHE BROKE UP WITH HIM, BUT SHE LIED.  SO, I CONFRONTED HER AND YEA SHE WAS EXTERMELY UPSET THAT I INVADED HER PRIVACY, BUT MY FEELING WAS AND I MAYBE WRONG, AS LONG AS YOU LIVE HERE AND I PAY THE BILLS FOR THE INTERNET AND THE PHONE I HAVE EVER RIGHT TO READ YOUR STUFF.  AFTER READING HER MY SPACE I FELT SICK, NOT JUST BECAUSE SHE LIED, BUT BECAUSE I NEVER WANTED TO BE A MOTHER WHO WOULD INVADE MY CHILDREN'S PRIVACY.  IN THE END THOUGH IT REALLY WORKED OUT BECAUSE SHE TOLD HER BOYFRIEND AND TOLD HIM LET'S JUST BE FRIENDS UNTIL MY PARENTS CAN WARM UP TO THE FACT THAT YOU ARE BACK IN MY LIFE.  HE TOLD HER THAT WAS A GOOD IDEA BECAUSE SINCE HE HAD BEEN BACK WITH HER HE COULDN'T QUIT THINKING ABOUT HIS EX-GIRLFRIEND. SO I SAY IT PAYS TO CHECK UP ON YOUR KIDS. THAT JUST MAKES YOU A CARING AND CONCERNED PARENT.

CherylAnn Community Member 11 posts since
Apr 7, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
4. Apr 18, 2009 10:59 AM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I dont think it is wrong. I too read my daughters texting on Aim.  I am so glad that I started. She was dating a boy that I wasnt' to sure about.  He was strange.  So I decided to read her conversations. I found out that he did drugs and alcohol and had a gun.   When my husband and I called the school and spoke with the principle, we found out that he was on probation and we went from there with the principle. Thank the Lord, she doesn't see him anymore. I did confront her about the fact that I was reading them. she was a little upset, but I told her that she is under age, and I feel I have the right. I told her I would continue to read..  My fear of telling her was that she wouldn't  talk about what she is up to, because she wouldn't want  me to know, but to my surprise she will every now and then say something  that will get her in trouble. I just found out that she has riden in a car with a friend, which she knows she isn't allowed at this time ( she is 16) I haven't confronted her yet, but I will.....

mysonsmylife Community Member 4 posts since
Apr 10, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
5. Apr 20, 2009 1:00 PM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I do not know whether or not it is wrong or not to read their messages, but it feels like the right thing, so I do. I have three teenage sons and I have made it very clear to them since they got their cell phones, my space, etc. that if at any time, I feel like there safety is threatened or suspicious of something they might be doing, or uneasy, I have the right as a parent to look at their texts, my space, etc.. Why? because trust is a privilege!They have to provide me with their passwords and if I ever try to get on and cannot, they will lose that privileged.

We are dealing with an issue right now, with my middle son and I wouldn't have known if he hadn't snuck out one night, and I took away his phone b/c I new he was not telling me everything. Unfortunately, I did learn of a very disturbing thing from his phone and am so heartbroken, I can hardly breath, but if I hadn't read his texts, who knows where we would be months from now. I have now changed his password on his computer and he has no phone. All of our computers in the house have passwords, and all of the passwords have been changed. I haven't yet, but have learned that I can also change his password on his my space in case he tries from someone else's computer or phone. He has been told that trust is earned and that it is all about "Smart choices". when he is able to make smart choices again, and begin to regain some of the trust, he will start receiving some of his privileges back. The motto at our house is "Smart choices" result in more privileges and freedom!

I truly believe that in this day and time that we live in, we as parents have to do whatever it takes to protect them and their futures! With all the predators out there, we have to go the extra mile.

As far as, texting in the  language that you referred to, in my experience with them, The rule is, If I can read it and it not result in any embarrassment or anger on my part, then it is appropriate, otherwise don't text it. It might also help you to tell your daughter, that when I did find those messages on one of my son's phone from a girl, it completely changed my view of the young girl, so what's to say that if the young girl's parents did the same thing that I did, what would they think of you? And as far as "sexting", I told my boys that would make lots of parents out there think very little of them and not want their daughters to date them.

jenn2009 Community Member 1 posts since
Apr 21, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
6. Apr 21, 2009 2:48 PM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I saw a story on FoxNews a couple of weeks ago about "sexting". A young girl had sent an inappropriate picture to her boyfriend and he in turn forwarded it on to several people. The young girl committed suicide. They interviewed the mother of the girl and the one thing she said that really stuck with me was telling parents to read their teens texts, and to be involved. That night I informed my two teenagers - 13 and 14 - that I would be reading text messages at will - could be any time. My son - the rule follower of the family has never given me concern, however my 14 year old daughter is another story - and since that time many things have come to light that have broken my heart.

 

I believe as parents, we have every right - every duty - to monitor the communication our kids are having. There are so many more modes of communication these days - and so many teens are left to their own devices by parents who don't monitor. There are things being said and done by teens these days that they are not emotionally or physically mature enough to handle. As parents, we need to watch out for our kids and make sure behaviors are appropriate. My daughter likes to use the phrase "I am almost 15". I informed her that while that may be true, 15 isn't any different than 14. 16 isn't much better, 17 is getting closer, and once she is 18 she is considered an adult and she is responsible for her own actions and behaviors. Until that time, she is my responsibility and she lives by my rules.

dovepair Community Member 317 posts since
Jul 17, 2007
Currently Being Moderated
7. Apr 21, 2009 5:16 PM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I have 3 teenaged boys and I randomly read their text messages and check out their myspace accounts.  I will go so far as to ask them for their phone so I can read them.  I have also asked them for their passwords to their myspace and e-mail accounts and periodically review them.  They know this and don't have a problem with it.  If they start throwing a fit about it then they probably have something to hide.

sdplu3 Community Member 2 posts since
Apr 22, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
8. Apr 22, 2009 1:22 PM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

You know, I have struggled with this very same issue lately.  I have a 14 year old daughter and I recently began going through her texts.  I have found things that make me want to cringe.  I would have never known, had I not looked.

 

I thought that I had a really great relationship with my daughter, until I discovered what she has been texting to people.  It seems like she's a totally different child around the house.  I just don't understand.  She's cussing, telling a boy she loves him and other things, too. I'm really glad I did look.

 

I never had a problem with my daughter until she got a cell phone and began texting.  Now, because of the things she has said and done, she has lost her phone indefinitely.  You would think we had killed her dog or something.  She is extremely upset without it.  We even told her she could use the home phone whenever she wants, but that's not good enough.  I'm not going to give her the means to act inappropriately.

 

So, I think it is o.k. to check their texts.  I think it is our job as parents to make sure we are involved with our kids and that they are acting like they're supposed to.

 

This is a really awkward age for them.

genandedd4god Community Member 8 posts since
Apr 3, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
9. Apr 22, 2009 3:16 PM in response to: jenn2009
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

JENN,

THANK YOU

GEN

momof3teens Community Member 5 posts since
Apr 22, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
10. Apr 22, 2009 9:32 PM in response to: genandedd4god
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

Oh my, your post sounds like I could have written it except for the language although I never got the chance to find that out because my daughter would delete all her texts once she answered them so by the time she got home or by the time I had a chance to check them they were gone. I felt this was very suspicious behavior. I also noticed that after I got my kids unlimited texting I felt that I was losing touch with them but my 15 year old daughter especially and she also would not keep the rule of no texting after 10 p.m.- so I made a very unpopular decision and cancelled their texting on all phones. I do not regret it and since then she and I have gotten close again.

 

Yes, you should read her texts, her emails, search her room occasionally. Get in her business. That's good parenting no matter how mad it makes her. Good job, mom. Sheri

CherylAnn Community Member 11 posts since
Apr 7, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
11. Apr 23, 2009 7:48 AM in response to: sdplu3
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I too feel that my daughter is a different person when here with us. I asked her once which was the real her. The one that I see when I  am around her, or the one I read about.   I know that sometimes kids will say things to their friends so that they can be cool, but I keep telling her that if it's not the real her, then why say those things. People should like her for who she really is, not what she pretends to be. I am amazed too, how some of her friends drink alcohol. I told her that if I find out that she is drinking when she goes to a friends house, she will be in serious trouble and that if the parents are allowing it, or "looking the other way"  that I will have them arrested. I have heard stories of parents leaving their kids and friends alone and allowing them to drink. They justify it by saying that they are at home and not going anywhere or drivng.  One message I read last summer was of one kid asking if she was allowed to drink. He had invited her to a party. They planned on drinking all night. She told him that she wasn't, but what I didn't know wouldn't hurt me. Now, she never asked to go to this party, not sure if because she knew I wouldn't let her or that she was just telling him what he wanted to hear, so she could sond cool.  Oh, when ever she asks to go to a party, I call the parents and ask if there is going to be drinking and if they plan on staying there the whole evening. I think that embarrasses her somewhat, because she is 16, but I dont' care. I told her that it is my right as her parent. Like one parent said, we have to pray that God will keep them safe and help them make the right decisions. We have been listening to a pastor on the radio, which I also have downloaded her teachings and put on her mp3 player. She has been listening to him.  I am hoping that it will touch her as she says it has, and help her make the right choices in life.

MeanDad Community Member 20 posts since
May 18, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
12. Jun 26, 2009 2:16 PM in response to: CherylAnn
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I totally agree that it our job as parents to monitor our children at all appropriate levels!!  We as parents are liable for things that our children do, so we have to this!!

 

I not only believe in reading text and chat messages, but I have gone as far as putting a voice activated recorder in my oldest daughters room to listen when she talks about on the phone.  This allowed us to find out that she was going to a drinking party at age 17.  We used the information to just show up and catch her in the act.  I have also used a GPS tracking device which allowed us to find out where she was skipping school at and once we had a pattern, we made up an excuse to be in that area at that time.  It also allowed us to know that she was driving faster than 95 MPH!!  She has been a real challenge.    I also believe in random drug tests for your kids.  I told my kids early on that I will random drug test them whenever I want.  If they pass the drug test, I will give them $100, and if they fail, they will be drug tested every month until they pass a test and that they will not get paid moving forward.   So my kids beg me to drug test them so they can get $100.  I do it at least once a year just so they know that I will do it.  It also gives them an excuse to their friends when they are getting peer pressure to try drugs!!

 

In our house my kids are not given trust, they have to earn it.  I have told my kids early I am going to sneak up on them.  If I sneak up on them catch them doing things right, they earn and build my trust.  If I catch them doing things wrong, I am going to keep sneaking up on them until the earn my trust back.  If I catch them doing things RIGHT, they earn and build trust and I get bored, so I will back off until I see a reason to sneak up them.

 

My two cents at being a Dad!!

 

Mean Dad and comfortable with it because my kids are safe.  

funkyterp Community Member 1 posts since
May 22, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
13. May 22, 2009 10:07 AM in response to: CherylAnn
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

Thanks guys for this convo. We also have a 15 yr. old daughter who has changed alot with the advent of high school and the cell phone. Up until recently she just had a plain cell phone, no texting. We decided to give her an iphone with unlimited texting and she just doesn't appear able to handle using it responsibly, so now we are going to have to crack down on its usage. So thanks for some of the ideas in this thread on that angle. On the one hand, teens are allowed the privacy of their own thoughts and ideas, as individuals. In the past, they might have put them in a diary, journal, etc.  In the past, the playing field for possible indiscretions from teens was the home phone, but there are only so many places a kid can hide in the house and carry on a convo   Home computers and the facebooks of the world open up a whole new potential of bad, but still, parents can control their usage pretty good at home, making them be in a 'public' area. But the cell phone with texting is very impervious and opens up all kinds of potential for bad stuff. So i agree, the child being underage/our responsibility, with us paying for the phone and service, we as parents have not only the right, but the duty to monitor. It's inevitable your child will be exposed to bad stuff with this technology, so it's up to us to be the gatekeeper while at the same time trying to teach them how to use such things responsibly in the future.

momof3teens Community Member 5 posts since
Apr 22, 2009
Currently Being Moderated
14. May 22, 2009 10:05 PM in response to: FocusMember
Re: Is it wrong to read your teen's texts?

I wanted to add something about this post. If you ever have any doubt that you are doing the right thing by getting in your kids business by reading their texts just listen to this. In my own home town last week a little girls baseball coach was arrested after a 12 year old's mom read some texts on her phone from this man. He was planning to meet her daughter on the playground and take her back to his house to have relations with her. Her mom just happened to read the text right before the girl was aiming to meet him. She called the police and they took over assuming the girls identity and texting this man from her phone. He laid out in no uncertain terms what he wanted to do with her. How did her earn her trust in this way? Through inviting her to playdates with his niece. Please Mom's keep checking those texts.

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...