This thread is archived
1,711 Views 6 Replies Last post: Feb 15, 2010 1:22 PM by LauraFOTF RSS
Parentingwows Community Member 1 posts since
Feb 8, 2010
Currently Being Moderated

Feb 8, 2010 10:31 PM

My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?

My yougest daughter says she want to have permission to have a boyfriend and that her friend sparents have let their daughters have them. I don't think any child should be having boyfrieds at 11. She says that a boy has asked her to be his girlfriend and she is pressing us for an answer in letting her have one. She is concerned what he and others might think if she does not give an answer right away. I told her she should concentrate more on her school work, family and church activities. I also said that I needed time to talk with others about this and that I couldn't give her an answer right now. She knows that I don't really aprove of this but I am trying to listen to her and understand what she and why she is asking. Please tell me your thoughts of an 11 y/o girl having a boyfriend.

Tags: parenting
KristieMarina10 Community Member 1 posts since
Feb 9, 2010
Currently Being Moderated
1. Feb 9, 2010 8:20 AM in response to: Parentingwows
Re: My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?
I totally understand your concerns and know where you are coming from. I am a single, Christian mom. My daughter will be 11 in March and she has a "boyfriend." She and I are Christians. Her 11 yr old boyfriend is a Christian and just a wonderful young boy. His mom and dad are wonderful Christians and they just have a great marriage & family life. So, they set a great example for her....for us. I have been teaching my daughter the bible since she was 2. I have taught her God's plan for marriage, family and opposite sex relationships. Her dad left us when she was 2 and our 10 year marriage ended. So, my daughter does not remember living in a mom, dad & child home. I have never remarried. Obviously, when she started talking about a boyfriend.....when she was 9 I was very, very concerned. I did not like the idea at all and would not allow it. I talked to her many, many times about age appropriateness boyfriend/girlfriend relationships. My first thinking was.....she is desiring what she is not seeing at home. Then, I took a walk down memory lane....when I was her age. Well, I remembered getting those notes from a cute guy in class......Will you go with me? Check yes or no...lol This was all very innocent.....no kissing, holding hands or going out together on dates. Therefore, I throughly explained to Jessica what would and would not be allowed....giving her the biblical viewpoint. They have done activities together but his parents or myself are always with them plus it is in a public place. She has been a straight A student until her first year in middle school which is A/B honor roll thus far. They do not text or talk on the phone. He walks her out after school, carries her backpack when it is heavy, he handmakes her Valentine cards, makes her drawings and they have spent time talking about God together. My daughter is very open with me and tells me everything. They are very innocent and really do like each other a great deal. I changed my mind about the no boyfriend rule when I realized how innocent it all still is.....at this particular stage. On the flip side one of her friends has parents who have forbade her to have boyfriends and quite frankly not even like boys. This little girl likes them and has them but lies to her parents. I don't want that to happen with me and my daughter.....rebels start bucking at an early age. Guide her in God's word, pray about it and make the decision which best fits  your parenting model. I hope this helped and hope I didn't ramble on....God Bless you and  your family   BTW...her little "boyfriend" started pursuing her in 2nd grade....he made up his mind and told his parents that my daughter was the only girl for him....lol. She never gave in......he pursued her until 4th grade when she finally told him that she would be his girlfriend. He was shocked, red faced and started wringing his hands saying......"Oh my goodness.....what do I do now?" 
Ted_Slater Community Member 28 posts since
Jan 8, 2008
Currently Being Moderated
2. Feb 9, 2010 12:42 PM in response to: Parentingwows
Re: My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?

What is the *purpose* of dating? Why do it in the first place?

 

I would argue that the *purpose* of dating, among Christians in modern Western societies, is to find a spouse. And, as Christian author Joshua Harris prudently points out, you really shouldn't "pursue romance until you're really ready for commitment."

 

The research shows that the longer a couple is dating, the most likely it is that they engage in sexual activity. Pre-marital dating that lasts two years is difficult enough, as far as retaining one's purity. If your daughter marries young, at 18, and doesn't experience a break-up with this boy, that's seven years of dating. If she were to start dating now, she is setting herself up to either experience a painful break-up (or several break-ups) or to expose herself to increasingly hard-to-resist sexual temptations.

 

My counsel, then, for what it's worth, is not to allow your daughter to have a boyfriend.

jer2911 Community Member 4 posts since
Feb 3, 2010
Currently Being Moderated
3. Feb 10, 2010 6:30 AM in response to: Parentingwows
Re: My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?
I have four adult children, two married and two still at home.  I raised them alone - my husband left the home shen they were all fairly young. When it came to setting the rules about dating, I consulted, first, the Bible, and then several trusted Christian friends and fellow parents, Christian writings on the subject, and our pastor. There was no inconsistency among all these sources and it was clear to me that God designed romance and dating to be part of one's search for his or her future soulmate and spouse. It's hard to say exactly at what age that search should begin, and I suppose it's different for everyone, but it seems inconceivable that it should during childhood.  God wants us first to seek Him and develop a personal relationship with Him.  Putting aside the issue of sexual temptation, which is definitely a valid consideration that our children will have to face eventually when they begin dating, there are so many other reasons why kids should not have boyfriends/girlfriends at age 11.  I know this is a very unpopular view in today's culture, but I have no regrets about my decision to not let my kids have "official" boy/girlfriends until they were old enough to date, which in our house was age 16, and even then, they could only date other committed Christians.
LauraFOTF Focus Employee 319 posts since
Nov 10, 2008
Currently Being Moderated
4. Feb 11, 2010 9:52 AM in response to: jer2911
Re: My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?

Ah, the magic age~ 16

 

That's the age we set for our girls to date too, although, I'd like to put it off.............until sometime in their mid-20's-----or 30's

As jer2911 points out, this type of restraint in entering the boyfriend/girlfriend stage, is an unpopular notion in our culture, where young children are exposed early via TV and other venues to the idea of dating- way before it is appropriate (in my opinion!).

 

With our family, my husband and I are not trying to raise kids who fit into this norm. We are thinking long-term.  My girls are 15 (turning 16 this month!) 12, and 5.  One thing I've always told them is that each family has different "family rules," so there will be differences in what other kids are allowed or not allowed to do. This, we have done since they were little and so they know that we are not going to be easily swayed by some other parent allowing something that we don't. As they get older, we are open to more dialogue about things, but still, some things are non-negotiable.

 

Parentingwows, to the point of "calling" one another boyfriend/girlfriend- (even though not technically dating) that's not allowed in our family-- but, my girls do have friends who are boys-- and they have since they were small. They are in touch regularly with each other via email, etc. I consider that different than boyfriend/girlfriend, and for us we have decided it is not terminology that will be allowed, as we feel, for us, it is inappropriate.  Because of that, they have all remained good friends without the drama of boyfriend/girlfriend stuff.

 

I'll share also, something I did with my daughter (the 12 year old) when we went away last summer for our Preparing for Adolescence weekend. I got a ribbon, and cut it about 100 inches long. Each inch was to symbolize a year in her life.  Now, the reason I chose 100 is that my grandfather is 101 right now, and so, I told her that while we don't know how long we'll be on earth, since Great-granddaddy is 101, there's a chance she may live long, too-- 

 

Anyway, we talked about how loooooooooong that ribbon was. Then I tied a knot about 11 inches in. And I told her that is where she is now. Then we talked about how it sometimes feels like forever until you are considered "grown-up." But then, I tied  knot between 18 and 20 inches.  If you picture that in your mind-- it's not that much farther in the context of 100 inches. I explained to her that the vast number of inches beyond that last knot represents ALL the time she'd spend as an adult.  She understood, at that point, why we feel no need to rush things as she grows up.  We want her to have fun as a tween and then as a teen- and to be clear on the fact that adulthood is just around the corner-- but not here yet

 

Now, for my teen, the age of 16 is looming. She already knows, however, that her dad will be interviewing any potential date. We got that concept from Dennis Rainey's Interviewing Your Daughter's Date.  Funny, and also a quick and really helpful read. Beware, boys with ill-intent! Also, we try to keep our girls very close. Our family unit is most important to us.  So we use some of the concepts from Home Court Advantage- which also heralds unusual ideas like keeping your kids home more-- rather than having them all involved in 3 sports, 2 clubs and no time to actually be home (another somewhat unpopular notion in our culture)

 

Finally, I really like the things Ted Slater has written here about his view of dating.  It is really not necessary until young adults are heading for a marriage commitment. A lot of wisdom there!

 

Hang in there fellow parents!

 

Laura

FOTF Moderator

Ted_Slater Community Member 28 posts since
Jan 8, 2008
Currently Being Moderated
5. Feb 15, 2010 11:21 AM in response to: LauraFOTF
Re: My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?

Laura -- you make some great points! I appreciate your perspective.

 

You wrote: "Beware, boys with ill-intent!"

 

Which makes me wonder: At 16 years old, and if dating is a time for Christian singles to evaluate the Lord's will regarding marriage, what does "good intent" look like?

 

Practically speaking, 16 is usually too young in my opinion. A 16-year-old couple will spend another year or two in high school, and then go off to college, likely to different colleges. And since such long-distance relationships rarely work out, they'll break up. So letting a 16-year-old start dating is just setting them up for heartache (again, in my opinion).

 

Or consider: People change SO MUCH in their late teens and early 20s, and going off to college catalyzes this change; it's likely that the 16-year-old couple that thinks they have so much in common will be significantly different people by the end of their teen years. And so, again, they'll be likely to break up, and consequently suffer heartache.

 

Ultimately, I suppose, the decision about whether or not to allow a 16-year-old to have a boyfriend is based on what we think the *purpose* of one-on-one dating is. If it's socialization or some other kind of un-intentional exploration, then a parent may encourage it. If it's a time to find a spouse, then a parent is likely to discourage it.

 

Of course, if a parent is fine with their child marrying at a relatively young age (e.g., 18 years old), then dating at 16 is just fine. I had a roommate who married a young woman who was 19 years old, and that was just fine.

LauraFOTF Focus Employee 319 posts since
Nov 10, 2008
Currently Being Moderated
6. Feb 15, 2010 6:44 PM in response to: Ted_Slater
Re: My 11 year old girl wants to have a boyfriend! what age is appropriate?

Hey--thanks, Ted, for explaining your point of view in more detail. It's obvious that there are a number of ways Christians can approach this subject. 

 

One of my dearest friends went that route and didn't kiss her intended until their wedding day. It can definitely be one good option, especially if you raise your children with these concepts as part of your family DNA.  In fact, when it comes to dating issues, as you know, we've had Joshua Harris and others on our broadcast and offered books from folks who do not encourage dating. They feel, like you do-- when the time is right and kids are old enough to marry, courtship is the way to go. 

 

On the other hand, we've had others on who say dating (and particularly group dating -- with no one-on-one connecting) can be useful in helping teens learn about the opposite sex in a non-threatening setting. For me, I'd rather lock them all away until they're 30! Ultimately, God has placed each of us in our children's lives to guide them in this area- and others-- I believe that parents need to prayerfully explore these different views and then make the decision on how their family will approach the question of dating.

 

Laura

FOTF Moderator

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...