Wow...I can relate. I'm getting married this summer and I have a deep and abiding fear that in spite of all the compliments on how pretty he thinks I am, once my future husband sees the parts of me I've kept carefully hidden (and we've never even been in bathing suits together, so that's a lot) he's going to feel cheated that he stayed pure until his thirties to marry a fat girl.
On a discussion thread over on Boundless a couple of years back, a young man commented something to the effect of "If you're a Christian, you know that you're only going to sleep with one girl, and that's going to be the girl you marry. So if you want to marry a babe, you need to only date women who are babes." Just knowing that there are guys out there who feel like that is so damaging, and makes me wonder if my fiance isn't going to wake up one morning and realize that he really wanted a babe - even though he's never once made a negative remark about my appearance, and reminds me frequently that he finds me attractive.
Good to know I'm not alone in feeling insecure even in the face of love and compliments. I still struggle with feeling like he's just saying I'm pretty so I'll feel better about myself.
"Just the other day, when we were visiting family in Florida, I refused to let Kevin carry me piggyback on the beach. My inner voice accused: You're too heavy! He'll have to put you down and then you'll be embarrassed"
Lol. Your weight aside, I think you give Kevin - and guys in general - less credit than they deserve
Compared to women, guys are strong. Even 'weak' guys. My brother's 5 years younger than me, and he's been able to lift me (at least piggy-back style) ever since he was about ten years old.
Also, Kevin wouldn't have offered if he wasn't sure he could carry you!
He probably would have found it embarrassing too if he had to put you down.
An interesting fact I discovered while preparing for marriage (I found it in the book "For Women Only", and my husband confirmed it), is that your husband does not care if you are overweight; what they care about is your attitude towards it, and towards them. If you are overweight and all you do is whinge and eat donuts and watch TV, your husband is going to feel unloved, because it looks like you don't care enough about him to put effort into your appearance. Similarly, if you are overweight but eat well and exercise, he won't care if you're overweight or not; you're putting the effort in and TRYING to be healthy and look good. And that shows him you love him. That's what's important to him.
The author of "For Women Only" used the example of her post-baby fat after she had their first child. She said it bothered her husband when she'd complain about her weight and then eat a donut for breakfast. But then she realised what she was doing, and instead started eating healthy breakfasts and going for a jog in the mornings. She didn't lose the weight immediately, but it made her husband much happier; she was making an effort, and that was all he cared about.
Joy - I understand why you felt that commenter's comment was damaging, and I don't know the context of it, but is it possible you took it the wrong way? I think it's quite plausible that the commenter was pointing out, if a guy is dating you, he obviously thinks you're a babe anyway. I am sure no guy out there would date a girl he found unattractive - so that guy's comment wasn't totally off-track.