Currently Being Moderated
5

In-Law Issues

Posted by Ashley_Ramsey on Sep 22, 2009 12:49:31 PM

In the months leading up to our wedding Brian and I read a lot of pre-marital books. It's probably more accurate to say I read a lot of books and narrowed down the really good ones for Brian to read. There were chapters in all the books we read about dealing with in-laws. As far as marital problems go it sounded like in-laws are right up there with sex and money. Before reading those books I was excited about the new family that Brian and I were gaining by getting married. But everything we were reading made me a little nervous about running into in-law issues.

 

During the time my anxiety was building I had a bridal shower where Brian's mother did something that eased my fears and set an extraordinary example of motherhood. When I opened her gift there was her apron that I had worn many times while cooking at their house. At first I thought she was giving me her apron (which would have been awesome because I've always admired it) and and then she stood up and said that there was another part to the gift she wanted to read to me. She opened a sheet of printed paper folded like a card and began to read:

 

Dear Ashley,

 

As I cut these apron strings in my relationship with Brian and give them to you, they come with the following promises ...

 

I promise to give you and Brian privacy and independence. I will never "drop by" without calling to ask if a visit is convenient. I will respect your boundaries.

 

I promise to not put pressure on you to produce grandchildren.

 

I promise to never gossip about you. I will defend you and promote you to others.

 

I promise to keep my opinions about your housekeeping, cooking, finances, personal tastes and parenting to myself. I promise not to give unsolicited advice about the way you live.

 

I promise to be flexible about the holidays. I will enjoy being with you whenever we can be together.

 

I promise to never feed your children "forbidden foods." I will uphold all of your house rules.

 

You and Brian will be a new family unit, with unique characteristics. I promise to cheer you both on in that uniqueness.

 

I promise to support your marriage over my relationship with Brian. You are the number one woman in his life.

 

I promise to pray for you, love you and respect you as I do my other daughters.

 

With God's help, I promise these things joyfully and sincerely and this old apron with it's newly grafted strings will be a reminder to me of these promises.

 

New Image.JPGAnd with that, she cut the strings off of her old apron and gave them to me. It's only been three months since those promises were made (I'm the resident newlywed) but so far every one of them has been kept. Even though my in-laws have done their part, I'm learning that it takes both parties to prevent the in-law issues I'd heard so much about.

 

There are days when problems arise and my first reaction is to call my mom. For the last 20 years she's helped me sort through crises and comforted me when I'm near inconsolable. Brian and I don't have a 20-year history and he doesn't always know what to say when I'm sad or stressed, but if I go with my first reaction to call my mom, he will never get the chance to learn. By making the choice to take my problems to my husband I'm sometimes left feeling misunderstood, but other times my emotional needs are met in a way no one else (including my mother) could have. And even when my needs aren't met in the way I wish they were, it's worth it because becoming one is a higher value than always feeling understood.

 

As Ted would say, I'm no in-law expert but I have a hunch that healthy in-law relationships depend more on the couple's priority to cleave to their spouse than the in-law's promise to respect their boundaries.

1,178 Views Twitter Facebook Tags: boundaries, in-laws


Add a comment Leave a comment on this blog post.
Sep 23, 2009 2:19 PM Guest Meme  says:

WOW. I wish my mother in-law would of and would do this. I have been married for 17 years and we have a serious boundries issue with my in-laws. They come over unannouced all the time. We even think they stalk our house. They tell us all the time what we are doing wrong with raising our kids. As in our kids should not have a social life. In her words "the world is dangerous". Yes my sister in-law still lives at home and she is 33 years old.(no job) So I guess my mother in-law has her scared her of the world. My husband and I have a different view on how we want to raise our kids. And live our life as a family. She has told us she does not like our church as well. We have heard all the horrible things about it that she has heard through the grape vine. We like our church. We are not there for her! I wonder if I printed the above and gave it to her if she would understand what I really want out of our relationship? My husband has just given up and told me she is going to do what she wants not matter what my husband says. He has been trying for 17 years to get her to respect our boundaries and nothing has worked! I guess you finally just get tired. We are going to suggest family counseling.

Pray for me!

Sep 24, 2009 5:16 PM Ashley_Ramsey Ashley_Ramsey    says in response to Meme:

Meme,

 

I've been praying for your family. Thanks for sharing your story. The Focus on the Family counselors might be able to recommend a good family counselor if that's the route your family decides to take. 1-800-AFAMILY.

Sep 24, 2009 5:21 PM Guest h.k  says:

Like the person above, the first word that came to mind was WOW. How blessed you are to have a MIL like that!

I am just past the one year mark in marriage and I am still not comfortable with my in-laws at all. They expect a lot out of me due to cultural traditions and personality and I just am not willing to give in so easily. I never thought I would be so stubborn but it's difficult. It has definitely helped that my husband stands up for me (although there were some arguments to get to that point) but it is still so uncomfortable I pretty much try to avoid calling them as much as I can since we've left the state our parents are in.

I remember reading about this in our premarital counseling books but I'm kinda lost and I'm not sure what I want in terms of what kind of relationship I desire with my in-laws.

Oct 8, 2009 6:13 PM Guest Leah  says:

"I have a hunch that healthy in-law relationships depend more on the couple's priority to cleave to their spouse than the in-law's promise to respect their boundaries."

 

I disagree with this. I don't have significant in-law problems, but I've read and heard of many problems and in all the situations I've heard of, the couple has had a great relationship - sometimes they've been together over 15 years and the cleaving thing is truly not an issue - but one of the in-laws is still being interfering. I think there are two types of in-law problems; 1) the truly interfering in-law, 2) when you're a newly married and some of your in-law problems may stem from your process of figuring out your relationships with the two families.

 

My mother and Nanna (her MIL) generally got along very well, but there were times as I got older that I had to bite my tongue to stop myself lashing out at Nanna who was criticising my mother or interfering. Don't get me wrong; generally I adored Nanna, and as she lived 1000km+ away we only saw each other once every year or two when she'd come to visit for a month or so. But I can think of times Nanna tried to tell my mother (after Mum and Dad had been married more than 20 years) that a certain cooking or food storage method was wrong, and there were times Mum would be disciplining us and Nanna would interfere. She'd usually be supporting Mum but her 'help' was never asked for.

 

I generally get along quite well with my MIL. I do wish she'd be as proactive about cutting the apron strings as your MIL was though. We've been married almost 18 months now, and there are times she tries to work us into plans without first checking we actually want to be involved. This really isn't bad, and she doesn't cause a scene if we opt out, but I guess it just feels like she's still treating us as her children, if you get my gist? They have also invited themselves around once or twice - they always call first, but the way she talks suggests she's just checking we're home and doesn't leave much opening for us to say 'no'. I definitely have one of the more amicable MILs out there though.

Oct 20, 2009 1:57 AM Guest Callie  says:

Thanks for posting this!  I do agree with your statement that "healthy in-law relationships depend more on the couple's priority to cleave to their spouse than the in-law's promise to respect their boundaries."  It definitely helps when in laws share the vision and release their children to cleave to one another, but having the security that you are loyal to each other first and foremost can really help minimize how you experience any problems with parents that might arrise!  From my experience, the greatest problem with in-law conflict is how it can put stress on your marriage.  If you're cleaving propperly, honoring the needs of your spouse above the desires of your parents, that stress goes away!

 

What a wonderful Mother-in-law to even recognize what your needs might be!   Don't ever forget what a blessing that is!