Plugged In

2 Posts tagged with the abortion tag
football stadium.JPGIt's amazing what dust an eensy-weensy Super Bowl ad can stir up.

 

As some of you may have heard, Focus on the Family (Plugged In's parent organization) will be airing a commercial during the Big Game this weekend. The ad—featuring former Florida Gators quarterback Tim Tebow and his mom—has become a pretty big deal around here—so much so that execs have taken to wearing shoulder pads and doing chest bumps in the hall. Morning devotionals are sounding more and more like play calls ("Isaiah 26:12 … hike!"). And I'm expecting Dippin' Dots vendors to show up sometime today.

 

But if the Super Bowl ad has triggered a certain eccentricity on the Focus campus, it's made some folks positively apoplectic outside it.

 

I've not seen the ad. My boss has not seen the ad. My boss's boss has not seen the ad. Very few of us inside the building have seen it, much less outside our pleasant, cubicle-lined confines. Nevertheless, several groups have asked CBS to yank the thing.

 

"By offering one of the most coveted advertising spots of the year to an anti-equality, anti-choice, homophobic organization, CBS is aligning itself with a political stance that will damage its reputation, alienate viewers, and discourage consumers from supporting its shows and advertisers," read, in part, a letter to the network signed by a number of women's groups.

 

Sports columnist Gregg Doyel, who writes for cbssports.com, took a different tack: "If you're a sports fan, and I am, that's the holiest day of the year. It's not a day to discuss abortion."

 

The ironies, of course, abound. I mean, we're talking about a sporting event that features advertisements devoted to beer, scantily clad women and folks getting thwacked in the crotch.

 

"Objectionable, after all, is in the eye of the beholder," wrote James Poniewozik, television columnist for Time magazine. "It seems ridiculous to start saying that espousing religion … is objectionable in an ad environment of alcohol-pushing animals, slapstick violence and Danica Patrick's cleavage."

 

For a while, news-related searches for Focus' ad dominated Google. And maybe that's not too surprising since our media culture loves a good row. But my guess is that when folks actually see the ad their reaction will be along the lines of, "Wow. And groups were up in arms over this? An ad celebrating families?"

 

When I was a religion reporter at a Colorado newspaper, I covered Focus on the Family quite a bit. And I learned pretty quickly that some people love the organization and some people—well, don't.

 

Now, frankly, I can understand why some folks might disagree with elements of what Focus does: We don't shy away from wading through controversial waters when conviction calls and Scripture specifies. That's part of what the leaders here feel called to do. But back in the day, one of my sources told me something that feels pretty appropriate right about now:

 

"Focus is about as controversial as flossing your teeth."

 

And really, when it comes right down to it, that's how Focus perceives itself: a dispensary of oral hygiene tools—which might hurt a little at the time, but are designed to help and heal, not harm.

0 Comments Permalink Just Wait 'Til They See the Ad!Twitter Facebook Tags: abortion, media, culture, focus_on_the_family, influence, football, super_bowl, tim_tebow, pro_life, pro_choice

Law, Order & Abortion

Posted by Adam_Holz Oct 28, 2009
Here’s a pop quiz on the subject of abortion: Where do you think the following quotes come from?

 

"I grew up thinking Roe v. Wade was gospel and that a woman’s right to privacy was inviolate. But after hearing that woman on the stand talk about her baby dying in her arms, I don’t know. I don’t know where privacy ends and another person’s dignity begins."

 

"In its day, Roe v. Wade conformed to what we knew about human life and science. Contraception was limited. Most birth defects were untreatable. Thirty-five years later, birth defects can be corrected. Disabled children are protected by a bill of rights. Contraception of every kind is available. [But] cats and dogs have more rights than the unborn. Roe v. Wade wasn’t written in stone. It could stand another look."

 

So, are these quotes from: a.) A pro-life pamphlet?

b.) A cable talk show?

c.) An upcoming Christian movie called Hidden Life?

d.) Prosecutors on last week’s episode of NBC’s Law & Order?

 

Surprise! It’s "d."

 

law&order.JPG Law & Order has a long history of creating fictional storylines (which the producer take pains to point out in a disclaimer before the show) that mirror the headlines of the day. Earlier this year, a late-term abortion provider in Kansas was shot and killed in his church in Wichita. Fast-forward a couple of months, and the scribes behind this popular, long-running legal procedural have crafted a very similar storyline.

 

Despite the disclaimer, the episode ("Dignity") begins exactly the same way the real-life story did, with a man shooting and killing a late-term abortion provider in church. In the course of bringing him to justice, the episode explores the subject of abortion with surprising sensitivity to the different stances on this issue.

 

Advocates of the pro-life position often get reduced to fanatical, one-dimensional stereotypes in many portrayals on TV and the big screen. The opposite tends to be true as well: The pro-choice stance is assumed to be the "correct" one. This episode of Law & Order doesn’t do that. It represents the pro-life arguments and convictions with nuance and respect.

 

"What’s up?" asked pro-life activist Jill Stanek in an article on the pro/con abortion website opposingviews.com. "In a town bent on stirring controversy, does Hollywood now think the pro-life view is in, hot—the new gay? Or perhaps NBC is trying to recoup lost mainstream viewers? Or most likely, since L&O’s previous 2 episodes dealing with abortion slanted way left, this was its attempt at balance? Whatever, I’ll take it."

 

Me too.

 

What do you think?

3 Comments Permalink Law, Order & AbortionTwitter Facebook Tags: abortion, killing, murder, justice, television, abortionist, law_&_order, nbc