Currently Being Moderated
4

Violin and Nokia Duet in A (for Annoying) Minor

Posted by Bob_Hoose on Jan 27, 2012 7:54:20 AM
We've all been there, that quiet time in the middle of a great movie or maybe a sweet moment while enjoying an intimate dinner with a loved one, when out of the blue somebody's cell phone starts bleating out its attention-demanding caterwaul.

 

All too often that offending bit of tech is screaming from the depths of someone's purse or well-buttoned back pocket. And so we have the pleasure of hearing its obnoxious ring at least two or three times. You think we'd be used to it. But even though just about all of us are attached to some kind of mobile appliance, it can still be irritating. And it can be particularly so during a live event like a concert, play or public address.

 

I read not long ago about some person who forgot to silence their phone while attending a New York Philharmonic performance. And when the thing started ringing they tried to be nonchalant and ignore it so people wouldn't think that they were the knucklehead interrupting the beautiful concert. The problem is, the phone just kept on ringing. And it's hard to miss a Marimba ringtone in the midst of Mahler's Ninth. So the conductor actually stopped the concert and publically embarrassed the offender while concertgoers yelled, "Throw him out!"

 

You can almost feel sorry for that poor guy. Well … maybe not.

 

Anyway, there's a video that recently splashed across Facebook of a similar cell phone incident that you may or may not have seen. But just in case you haven't, I thought I'd bring it to your attention.

 

Slovak violist Lukáš Kmit was in the midst of his recital when a mean old cell started vying for the audience's attention. But Mr. Kmit handles himself quite differently than the Philharmonic conductor. Take a look.

 

 

You can tell he was a bit put off. But he turned things around in a unique way, pleased the audience, and with a wink and a smile, got the guy with the phone to turn the silly thing off without throwing him to the wolves. Now that's worth a "bravo" or two.

 

And isn't this situation sort of a metaphor for life nowadays? We know that we can't always avoid the annoying things that often invade our lives. But perhaps if we take a cue from Lukáš Kmit we can incorporate those burrs and brambles into the melody of our day and make something beautiful of it.

2,411 Views Twitter Facebook Tags: music, phone, technology, concert, cell_phones, interruption, violin


Add a comment Leave a comment on this blog post.
Jan 27, 2012 4:29 PM Guest Name  says:
I myself play the violin. When I play it, especially with an orhestra, the sound resounds and the beautiful music swells. So I'll say that I was more than impressed with this man's performance. After all, how many people can play that ringtone after being interrupted. Not me.
Jan 27, 2012 8:12 PM Guest Abby  says:

It is my understanding that the cell phone offender at the New York Philharmonic concert later apologized to Alan Gilbert and explained more fully what happened:

 

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/13/nyregion/ringing-finally-stopped-but-concertgoers-alarm-persists.html?_r=1

 

I do feel sorry and sad for this gentleman as it appears he did not know how to work his brand new company iPhone and didn't realize that some iPhone alarms are not silenced when the phone is put into standby or silent mode. I would guess that as a purchaser of season tickets for 20 years, he was fully aware of how infuriating this situation often is to audience members and performers alike, and he seems quite embarrassed about it. His quote that he "didn't even know phones came with alarms" is a good hint as to his awareness of when it was going off during the concert.

 

As a professional violinist, I have experienced many interruptions to concerts and recitals: cell phones ringing, watches beeping, excessive coughing, little ones crying, etc. However, I would not wish to create a concert atmosphere where people did not feel welcome to come. I share my gifts as a way of wanting to bring glory to God and help people experience how He reveals some of His glory during classical music, which often speaks deeply into people's hearts. If I were to perform in a situation where audience members didn't feel welcome coming at the risk of ostracism due to things sometimes out of their control, then I would not want to perform. It's the human connection that I wish to preserve with my audience that keeps me practicing and performing.

 

I would argue that Mr. Kmit handled the similar situation with more grace than Mr. Gilbert did in his circumstance and I agree that we can learn from his patience when we face similar annoyances in our lives. "A gentle answer turns away wrath," after all.

Jan 28, 2012 6:04 AM Guest Lisbeth  says:
There are quite a few people who've humiliated audience members whose cell phones have gone off during a live performance.  British stage actor Richard Griffiths (Uncle Vernon from "Harry Potter") is notorious for halting performances to draw negative attention to people with ringing cellphones.  I think Hugh Jackman also halted a performance once because of a ringing cell phone.  As for me, I did a lot of theater in high school and, when a phone went off, it was so annoying because it drew everyone's attention to the phone.  My drama teacher had all sorts of stories of parents who let their phones ring willy-nilly, parents who couldn't find their ringing phones, and parents who didn't know how to turn off their phones and had to have a younger family member do it for them.  He said one parent actually took a call DURING a show and drowned out the voices of the actors on-stage.  The other annoying thing: FLASH PHOTOGRAPHY.  I attended my high school's production of "The Crucible" and the whole time, the school photographer took pictures with a flash camera that made SO MUCH NOISE.  You could tell the actors were getting irritated, it was that annoying.
Jan 28, 2012 2:09 PM Guest Matt R.  says:
An unintended negative consequence of technology.  Good for him in adapting to the situation.