Currently Being Moderated
149

Roger Ebert's Curious Faith

Posted by Jim_Daly on Sep 28, 2011 7:08:16 AM

It would have been hard to grow up in America during the past 40 years having never seen or heard the name of Roger Ebert. The Chicago-based 69-year-old film critic was the first movie reviewer to win the Pulitzer Prize, in addition to hosting numerous television shows and penning a syndicated newspaper column.ebertclassic1.jpg

 

Mr. Ebert is paid to give his opinion, a job he takes very seriously. Although I prefer to get my reviews from our award-winning Plugged In team, I wouldn’t begin to wade into the deep waters of the movie review business. However, I have been intrigued by Mr. Ebert’s recent comments about faith, inspired, it would appear, by his nearly decade-long illness.

 

In 2002 Roger Ebert was diagnosed with thyroid cancer. Years of surgery followed, culminating with the removal of his jaw in 2006. Doctors didn’t expect him to survive, but thankfully he rallied and, although unable to speak, he is now able to communicate with the assistance of computer software.

 

Raised a Catholic, he has always appeared to respect people of faith – although he does not claim a personal belief in a living and loving God. Over these last few years, Roger Ebert has grown more blunt about his worldview, but also somewhat defensive. In 2009 he balked at the suggestion that he didn’t believe in a divine Creator, responding:

 

I have never said, although readers have freely informed me I am an atheist, an agnostic, or at the very least a secular humanist—which I am.

It has recently struck me that Mr. Ebert has devoted his life to judging the quality and creation of film, and yet he believes that he is living in a world not only without a judge, but also without a Creator. In his new memoir, Life Itself, Ebert appears to leave no room for the existence of God. Speaking of death he writes:ebertbook.jpg

I know it is coming, and I do not fear it, because I believe there is nothing on the other side of death to fear.

 

Many readers have informed me that it is a tragic and dreary business to go into death without faith. I don't feel that way. "Faith" is neutral. All depends on what is believed in. I have no desire to live forever.

 

What I expect to happen is that my body will fail, my mind will cease to function and that will be that.

 

I have never met Mr. Ebert, but I have met many people who think and believe as he does. So have you. Secular humanism is a faith alright, but it’s a faith without any roots. It’s a faith based upon trust and confidence in oneself, which is dangerous and, ultimately, catastrophic given the sinful nature of mankind. Unlike Christianity, secular humanism is defined by shifting and subjective standards. When pressed the secular humanist will acknowledge that life is random and without reason, even accidental. This is why when faced with tragedy and strife, the secular humanist is left with nowhere to turn, because in the end, well in Mr. Ebert’s own words, “that will be that.” All pain is relative and like secular humanism not redemptive, even hopeless.shumanism1.png

 

This stark contrast – the clash between Christianity and worldviews that deny God - is the greatest contest of our time. In whom and in what do you trust? Here at Focus on the Family we believe that the purpose of life is to know and glorify God through an authentic relationship with His Son, Jesus Christ. This purpose is lived out first within our own families then extended, in love, to an increasingly broken world that desperately needs Him.

 

Please join me in praying for Mr. Ebert and for those who are searching for ultimate meaning and purpose in life.

 

As always, I welcome your thoughts, perspective and feedback. Please let me know what you're thinking.

 

ALSO THIS WEEK:  Monday:  Leggo My Eggo   Tuesday: Video - Things You Don't Say to Your Wife

 

 

Follow me on Twitter @Dalyfocus

Follow me on Facebook

47,070 Views Twitter Facebook Tags: life_itself, roger_ebert


Add a comment Leave a comment on this blog post.
Sep 28, 2011 8:09 AM Guest Daren R.  says:
The quote by Protagoras illustrates the worldview behind Pilate's question, "What is truth?" If Jesus is the Truth, then there shouldnt' be any question that we Christians need fear, whether it involve science, ethics, or history. These arenas should be our playground.
Sep 28, 2011 5:27 PM Guest Kim  says:

Jim,

 

Thank you for this beautiful article. It is so well-stated, and shows care rather than criticism for Mr. Ebert. I couldn't agree more that there is a great need to build a relationship with Jesus Christ within our families, and then share that with the world that so badly needs Him.

Sep 28, 2011 4:40 PM Guest Dale W.  says:
If one thing can not be truer than another then there in no such thing as truth.  Is that the truth?
Sep 28, 2011 4:41 PM Guest Russell  says in response to Daren R.:
If he's right; I won't mind being wrong, there will be no consciousness after death.  If I'm right (Jesus is God in the flesh and spoke the truth); he'll be tormented in hell forever.  I'm sad about his trajectory towards death and his unwillingness to recognize Christ as Savior.  The Spirit is like the wind; no one knows where it comes from or where it will go.  If cancer won't humble him then perhaps nothing will.  Let's pray for his salvation.
Sep 28, 2011 4:43 PM Guest Andy  says:
Roger wrote, "I have no desire to live forever."  That's nice.  I wonder how he'll feel if in fact he will live forever outside of the presence of God.  He also writes, "Faith is neutral." I  don't believe ANYONE believes that, not even Webster's.  Faith needs an object.  Even if someone says that they have no faith; that is indeed a faith statement.  They have a hope that the nothingness they hope in is indeed reality.  Sad.
Sep 28, 2011 4:50 PM Guest Carrie  says:
How sad that Mr. Ebert feels that there is nothing beyond death.  I will be praying for him, knowing that even now God is still loving and waiting for him with open arms.  I myself can only look forward to that day when my earthly body will fail and I will be ushered into the loving arms of Jesus.  It is with great joy that those of us who know Jesus can look forward to death!
Sep 28, 2011 4:54 PM Guest Jamie  says:

To not believe that truth is objective is to not believe in the existance of truth.  In practice, however, people do believe in absolutes.  Absolute laws governing reality.  It's just sad that people don't make that connection and instead choose to customize a religion so that it never condemns them.

Sep 28, 2011 5:33 PM Guest Teresa W.  says:
The saddest commentary on any life is that the person died without ever having known the God of all creation.  Life ceases to have any meaning a part from Christ.  I pray that God will make himself know to Mr. Ebert.
Sep 28, 2011 4:58 PM Guest Niki  says:
I heard a statement today -  a quote from C.S. Lewis:"As long as what you  are afraid of is something evil, you may still hope that the good may  come to your rescue. But suppose you struggle through to the good and  find that it also is dreadful? How if food itself turns out to be the  very thing you can't eat, and home the very place you can't live, and  your very comforter the person who makes you uncomfortable? Then,  indeed, there is no rescue possible: the last card has been played.

C. S. LEWIS, Perelandra
(it seems to me that this eloquently identifies why a man may end up  feeling as Ebert does - perhaps people of today are not so afraid of  evil as they are of good)

 

 

Sep 28, 2011 4:58 PM Guest Dan  says:
I wish I had that courage to boldly say "I am not afraid.......There is nothing on the other side". I know when I was 26 I almost died in a car accident. I was driving fast in the rain, and started to skid, and I jammed on the brakes, and did a hydroplane into a patch of tall grass, and flipped my car. While the car was flipping I kept seeing visions of Hell. Let me tell you.......it's not a tropical paradise with everyone holding a glass of Pina Coloda, and Ricardo Montabon saying: "My dear guests I am Mr. Roarke your host. Welcome to Fantasy Island". The visions of Hell I saw were Brimstone, and Fire, and I was falling in a "Bottomless Pit". I can never again say "I'm not afraid to die".
Sep 28, 2011 5:01 PM Guest Believer  says:

To enter eternity with no hope.  How sad!

"my body will fail, my mind will cease to function and that will be that."  Boy, is he in for a rude awakening.

May he come to know the truth of the gospel before it's eternally too late.

Sep 28, 2011 5:03 PM Guest Susan  says:

It is so sad to hear when people such as Roger Ebert who has suffered so much in this life speak of no existance after death as they have no realization that their suffering will not end with their death but will continue on even more intensely eternally.  We must pity them and pray for them that the Lord will somehow have mercy on them and open their eyes to the truth before that last day comes upon them.   Makes one appreciate so much more what the Lord has done for us by giving us the "eyes to see" and the "ears to hear". A gift we can never pay back.

Sep 28, 2011 5:41 PM Guest Chris J.  says:
There's something in Ebert's center on "readers" that strikes me as interesting. It's like his memoir is a wrestling with the general public, a culture, of men. "Many readers have informed me" and "readers have freely informed me." Without God, I see such a wrestling match as unwinnable, and anyone would crumble to the world's weight.
Sep 28, 2011 5:15 PM Guest Sandi  says:
After reading your article about Roger Ebert and his faith, or lack thereof, all I know to do is to pray for him, and none of us can get prayed for too much.
Sep 28, 2011 5:43 PM Guest Alta M.  says:
Mr. Daly, I preface this by asking for your help. Would you help me sort out my feelings and thoughts? I'm not trying to be contentious. I'm actually desperately sad. You see, after reading your article I find that I agree with the statement "all pain is relative and hopeless". Before becoming a Christian and yes, even afterwards, I've struggled with the meaninglessness of humanity's suffering. I can mentally assent to the redemptiveness of Jesus' pain and the hope that His suffering brought about but even after all these years of searching the Scriptures and reading the works of saints stronger and braver than myself, "I still haven't found what I'm looking for." For how can the suffering of a child sex slave be redemptive? To whom? How can the starvation of a child not be hopeless? What purpose does it serve? I don't deny God. But like a secular humanist I see random suffering everywhere and there seems to be no rhyme or reason to it. Shriner's Children's Hospital is full of innocent children who suffer from terrible diseases. Most of Africa is engulfed in horrors beyond description. I can understand the redemptive factor in the suffering of persecuted Christians. They will earn a heavenly reward. But where is the reason, the meaning behind all the mundane, quotidian agony? To what does our faith cling when we hear of a child being sodomized by an abusive parent for example? In the face of such hellish realities that too often leave human beings reduced to mere wrecks we Christians shouldn't be so quick to offer platitudes. Even the writer of Ecclesiastes said it was better to have never been born or conceived.
Sep 28, 2011 5:20 PM Guest susan  says in response to Daren R.:
I agree.
Sep 28, 2011 5:36 PM Guest Tori  says:
Before I came to believe in God, He would send me "headscratchers." In one case, a dog had been hit by a car. Another driver and I stopped. The dog was in the middle of the road, so we grabbed a piece of plywood by the road and used it for a stretcher. I took her to the vet, then gave her to a family member. Six months later, it suddenly occured to me that it was a fantastic coincidence that a piece of wood just the right size for a dog stretcher was sitting right there where it was needed. I went from unbelief to hmm........... maybe?  There were other coincidences AKA God-incidences. My prayer for my fellow doubters is that God would send them plenty of headscratchers that help them find our wonderful creator!
Sep 28, 2011 5:46 PM Guest LaVonne T.  says:
I pity those who believe this is all there is, who accept it as fact. I long to live forever and I have that hope and promise. Pain and sorrow free too! What a blessed reward to be had by simply loving and giving all that I am to the One Who made you, me and Roger E. I will join in praying for Mr. Ebert, not so much for his jaw or inability to speak. But for his heart to be softly and tenderly opened to the awesome reality of God, for eyes to see and ears to hear and for everlasting life with our Father.
Sep 28, 2011 5:57 PM Guest Steve K.  says:
So sad about Mr Ebert!! To say there is no life after death is sad.  There are (2) lifes.  Heaven, and Hell.  Heaven is the most glorious place anyone could want to go and its free. All you need to do is have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ as your personal Lord and Savior!!! For people like Mr. Ebert his heaven is here on earth, he has no idea what he is heading to if he goes to Hell!!!  I will be praying that some how God touches  Mr Ebert heart through someone or something.  I just think about what Mr. Ebert could do as a testimony for the Kingdom if he was a Christian.
Sep 28, 2011 5:57 PM Guest Alice S.  says:

Last night, I spent quite a long time watching & listening to the history of a number of Roman Emperors, on one of the History Channels.  This was a stark & horribly sad revelation of the true meaning of life with no God but self.  And these sad beliefs have continued to the present.

Sep 28, 2011 6:03 PM Guest Denise  says:

He says his mind will fail and his body will go~~maybe he needs to learn that he has a spirit and his spirit is eternal.  Just a question of where will that go ??  Will be praying for him fervently.

The Lord does not want any to perish~~I know the Lord is always reaching out.

Sep 28, 2011 5:56 PM Guest MARIO  says:

What is the problem with trusting and believing in God? the only thing he wants to do is help us and bless us! I

don't understand the position of this world!...this are trully the last days...

Sep 28, 2011 6:07 PM Guest Billsey  says:

1 Corinthians 2:14 (NIV especially)

 

I humbly suggest that we focus not on the unequiped, but on the equiper, for He is the One who can effect change.

Sep 28, 2011 6:07 PM Guest gbrc  says:
May the grace of his baptism draw Mr. Ebert back to the faith of his youth.  God's indelible seal is on Mr. Ebert's soul.  Let's pray that he responds to the Lord's calling and offer of unfathomable Divine Mercy.
Sep 28, 2011 6:02 PM Guest Michaelaj99  says:
I too feel a sense of sadness for Mr. Ebert but also appreciate your words of concern and compassion rather than ridicule and disdain.  I wish he could experience the comfort and care of a loving God who wants nothing more than to have a loving relationship with him for a short time before he dies and for eternity thereafter.  A life , no matter how short, touched my Christ is a changed life indeed.
Sep 28, 2011 6:09 PM Guest gbrc  says in response to Alta M.:
It is not the pain and suffering that are redemptive, but God's action through the suffering and pain that make them redemtptive.  People wonder so often -- particularly after horrible natural disasters -- why a loving God would allow such a thing to happen.  We hear many stumble about, trying to find an answer and often coming up with, at best, "We can't know."  Well, we can know: why does He permit evil?  To bring about a greater good.  Look no further than the suffering and death of our Savior and the redemption of the world that God brought through it.
Sep 28, 2011 6:23 PM Guest Robby W.  says in response to Dan:

Dan,

 

There is a step beyond fear - a step of faith.  You are fortunate that the car wreck blessed you with fear, because so many have never experienced this blessing.  Now, Jesus Christ can bless you with faith.  "I can never again say 'I'm not afraid to die'."  I am not sure if what you have written is all of your story.  But, Jesus is ready to help you write the rest!

 

"There is no fear in love.  Because perfect love (Jesus Christ) casts out fear!"

 

Robby

Sep 28, 2011 6:23 PM Guest michelle v  says in response to Dan:
dan, have you come to know Jesus as your Savior now? find a Bible, read it, call out to Him in prayer, and He promises He will answer with salvation and comforting promises of heaven. i was in a near death accident at 17 as well and it led to facing my mortality and coming to know Christ at 21. will be praying.
Sep 28, 2011 6:13 PM Guest Stan  says in response to Alta M.:
Alta, I'm inclined to agree... the non-existentialist position of Mr. Daly is contrary to Scripture (particularly Ecclesiastes). Meaning exists, but it is not intrinsic; it is imputed by evaluative agents (including God and man).
There are no easy answers. We Christians do not have an easier time with the problems of pain and suffering in the world than do atheists. We have a harder time with them.
Additionally, "Man is the measure of all things" does not mean there is no objective truth; it means that an individual can never have 100% access to *observation-based truth* because he can only apprehend it through the facsimiles created by his perceptions (and we can say that this statement is objectively true, in a similar way that 1 + 1 = 2).
"One opinion can be better than another, but it cannot be truer," is also a misstatement of this position. Whether an opinion is better than another is exactly in terms of whether it is truer, and this view is shared by both us Christians and by most atheists, including outspoken ones like Dawkins and Harris.
Sep 28, 2011 6:14 PM Guest TD3  says in response to Alta M.:
Alta, I work in the health professions and I see pain each and every day.  Pain as the result of either internal or external factors.  Physical pain and emotional pain.  What I have come to understand about pain, (yes even for the sex slaves) is that a problem exists it may be self, culture or enviornmentally induced.  But I believe that our Creator has given us this ugly thing called pain to open our eyes, to seek answers and to hopefully seek Him.  Some of us deny and dull our pain.  I personally have seen provision in (my own) pain, as wierd as that may sound.  Seek. Continue to seek.  - Thank you for your transparency.  I pray that your questions are answered in a manner that confirms a redemptive faith in the Creator who surpasses all understanding.  - TD
Sep 28, 2011 6:16 PM Guest JR  says in response to Daren R.:

I agree. Interesting that, according to the gospel accounts, we find a budding faith in Pilate's wife. In her we see a genuine desire for truth, justice and hope regarding Jesus Christ. Yet on the contrary, we see the ultimate sort of secular humanism in Pilate himself. According to historical accounts, Pilate actually commits suicide... The irony being that, in the end, humanistic relativism is a form of spiritual suicide which both starts and finishes in one's own self. I sure do pray that Ebert and other folks like him can find Christ, the hope of glory. He is the only way, truth and life...

Sep 28, 2011 7:26 PM Guest Praise God for Jesus  says in response to Believer:
"In whom and in what do you trust?" is a question that was asked on this Focus on the Family Website.  I believe in Jesus and of His great love for all of mankind throughout the ages since Day One!!!!  I also will pray for this man and his soul.  I pray for pride which is a BIG sin, in itself, to give way to the softening of the Holy Spirit!  I think sometimes some humans may think this way as it is an easier way to NOT have to think about the inevitable...the finality of life.  One night when I was sleeping, I woke up abruptedly with a strange thing fluttering around my head and I heard the most horrible noise of all noises that my ears have ever heard of chains and as it states in the Bible, "the gnashing of teeth." The only thing that I did was say "Jesus, Jesus, Jesus" to myself and all of a sudden I saw a white light and then I went into the deepest of sleeps that I have ever, ever been in ever!!!  When I woke up I was so very refreshed in the morning!  The point of my little story is that no one, but no one can tell me that there is not a Heaven and a hell!!!!  How I pray that Roger Ebert will read what I have written for his benefit!! And for all people to read this who cannot or will not realize that the "absolute truth" is that there is a Heaven and a hell.  God died for everyones' sins in the form of His Son, Christ Jesus!!!
Sep 28, 2011 7:28 PM Guest Jeffrey L.  says:

I am not surprised at anyone who believes as he does. This existential belief is in my own home.

In a technological age, we are left with monetary safeguards, self help books and seminars that massage our bent ego's. I always look forward to having a discussion with someone of this caliper, however, all this does is remind me that "we do not wrestle with flesh and blood..." Only prayer in a faithless world will turn a hard heart.

 

Jeffrey L

A Masters College graduate

Sep 28, 2011 6:32 PM Guest Mary Ann P.  says:
You asked us to "let you know what we're thinking".  What I'm thinking is that I do not relish the thought of Mr. Ebert, a seemingly friendly, nice person, to spend eternity in a tormented place called Hell.  I'm glad you admonished us to pray for him. Too often we think of anyone who is seen on TV or in magazines or newspapers as not quite a real person.  But he is very much real; he has sufferred physically in a way that I cannot imagine; and I want him to be spared experiencing eternal separation from the One Who created him.  I WILL pray for him.  Thank you again for the reminder to do so.
Sep 28, 2011 7:30 PM Guest M C.  says:
Very sad - God gave him a chance.  And yet he still doesn't believe in him.  He will be surprised at the "nothing" after death that he believes in!  Guess we should pray that his heart will be open before its too late.
Sep 28, 2011 6:36 PM Guest Mary Ann P.  says in response to Tori:
Thank you, Tori, for this.  I love this account of God's "headscratchers".  Is it not amazing that the God Who owns and created everything would work so hard at helping us to see Him?  What a peek into the unbelievably loving heart of God!  Thank you for sharing this.
Sep 28, 2011 6:39 PM Guest Cyndi  says in response to Daren R.:
If one wants to live with Yah eternally, one must "shamar" His Torah - - - it is the Light, the Way, the Truth, and the Life - - - "Many will say to Me in that day, "Lord, Lord, we cast out demons in Your Name, we prophesied, etc., and I will say to them: "Depart from Me, you who are without Torah; I never knew you."  Obviously, they "believed" and had "faith", but did not "know" Him, and He did not "know" them.  We come to know Yah through His Torah.
Sep 28, 2011 7:32 PM Guest Cari M.  says:
I will pray for Mr Ebert - that he will find the joy of knowing God through Jesus Christ and pray that one day we will be together in Heaven with our loving Savior!
Sep 28, 2011 6:47 PM Guest Lindy  says in response to Russell:
Well said.
Sep 28, 2011 6:47 PM Guest Don K  says in response to gbrc:

To GBRC: Regarding your statement 'the grace of his baptism...save him'.  A ritual does not save anyone, especiallly words spoken over an unknowing infant with some water splashed on. God does not teach that and it is quite dangerous to trust such a concept. Just like everyone else, Roger Ebert and I must choose to excercise faith in Jesus Christ and receive his grace and forgiveness for our sin.

 

To Alta M: God does not cause or do any of the heinous things you point out. That is what the devil and men under his control and influence do. The devil wants to lie, steal, and kill, but God only wants our good and loves us. The devil wants men to think the evil in the world is somehow God's fault and doing.  God is not responsible for any of that , but only has demonstrated his love by paying for our sin on the cross.  He has given us spiritual tools and authority to counter the evil that is in the world. Let's band together and exercise our spiritual authority over evil and use the tools and means He's provided, in His Spirit. What else can we do?

Sep 28, 2011 6:48 PM Guest Mike S  says:
I think where you put the reference to roots, is key to the discussion.  For me it gives me a different perspective on faith and the parable of the sower and the seeds.  There were four places that the seeds fell, one of which was hard ground.  It had no roots.  For a long time I saw this as differening levels of Christianity, faith, hope love, now I see it from a different perspective, those who accept Christ's gift and those who don't.  It is a sad day when we all get to heaven and see those who are judged. I hope that in the end Mr. Ebert can come to a better understanding of the relationship that is true Christianity before he passes to answer to his maker.
Sep 28, 2011 7:59 PM Guest Ann-Marie P.  says:
Why would one chose nothingness after death rather than everlasting life? What was the point of your life then? I would rather chose to believe in faith, Chris's redemption and eternity with him than... People please do not let pride get in the way of where you will chose to spend your eternity.
Sep 28, 2011 6:56 PM Guest Elizabeth  says in response to Dan:
I appreciate your honesty.
Sep 28, 2011 8:02 PM Guest Tina W.  says in response to Alta M.:
Alta, I used to find myself wondering the same things. The fact is "stuff" happens and personally, I don't think God is punishing anyone or will punish anyone. You can not say "God IS LOVE" out of one side of your mouth and then say, "God will send you to eternal damnation" out of the other side of your mouth. God IS LOVE. God is all things. God is everywhere, in everything and everyone. Problem is we don't know who we are. Man has been defining God with his actions for thousands of years. Jesus came to "redefine" God with his actions and there was no judgement or damnation in anything he did. No one truly finds God out of fear. Anything "fear based" is not of God. Scaring the "hell" out of people doesn't lead them to God. He was showing us who WE ARE, so we can stop running around in this "physical" life experiencing who we ARE NOT.  He showed us that God lives in us. He set this life in motion in a way that we manifest what we believe. Every person, condition, circumstance in our life is perfectly there for our soul to chose and define, "who" we are. What we put out is what we will receive. These are the laws. If you put out hatred, despair, resentment, unforgiveness, then that is what you will experience. Look for the good in the world, in people, in everything and focus on it. You will find it. BE, the things you want to see and experience and you will experience them. Be LOVE,  be COMPASSION, be FORGIVENESS.  If you want to be forgiven, forgive. If you want love, love others. Jesus told us all these things. It is just written for a different time and different culture, but it is the same message. It is his message we need to get in order to be set free, not by picking apart the words. These are the absolutes. God is love and love can only go outward. It must. Look at the world around us, everything gives of itself for the good of the whole. When we begin to see who we are, we stop damning ourselves and start living as love. The world will change one person at a time. As individuals begin to live out of this love and stop "judging" everyone and everything, there will be a ripple effect and the collective spirit of the world will change. Look for the good. It is there to see. What you feed will grow. What you think, meditate or dwell on is what will grow. "HOPE", is what we put our faith in. Continue to have hope for a better world. God has got this!
Sep 28, 2011 7:06 PM Guest Elizabeth  says in response to Alta M.:

One theory as to why the pain and suffering goes:

 

We need to know what happens when we choose our own way.  All the repercussions.

 

If all scripture is for reproof, for correction, for instruction, and

If the Old Testament was primarily about God the Father, the New Testament is primarily about the Son, and the next one has yet to be written

Then perhaps what is happening today will be for others' reproof, correction and instruction tomorrow.

Sep 28, 2011 7:12 PM Guest Scott  says in response to Dale W.:
No, Dale, that's a lie from the Father of Lies.  If I may ask, why would you think that "one thing can not be truer than another"?
Sep 28, 2011 7:19 PM Guest Jason  says in response to Daren R.:
Daren, well said.
Sep 28, 2011 8:12 PM Guest Ross G.  says:
Great apologetic in response to a commonly held humanistic world view.  Thanks, Jim,  for providing us with  amunition for defending the faith.  Bless you my brother.
Sep 28, 2011 7:27 PM Guest Jason  says:

The Bible says that "a fool in his heart says there is no God". Yes, that would make Roger a fool, but were we not all fools before receiving Yeshua as Lord? "While were yet sinners (that includes fools), Christ died for us". ~ Romans 5:8. Thank God that He has a curious...and unending love. And thank you, Jim, for sharing this story. So many can now pray for Roger because of your faithful stewardship.

 

God bless,

Jason

Sep 28, 2011 7:40 PM Guest riverrat  says in response to Russell:

Andy. While I do not agree with Mr. Ebert, I also have an issue as to what you espouse. When an individual passes from this life, they do not enter into either heaven or hell. They go into a realm that is prepared for them by God. It is not Paradise either but more of a realm where they are waiting to be judged on that final day. It even mentions in the Bible that after Christ died on the cross, HE did not resurrect for 3 days. Where was HE? He went into the realms and met with the individuals from Noah's time. It didn't say he went to Hell nor to Heaven. God is the final judge, not us. We can only pray for the souls and hope they find succor in the prayers and are allowed to find grace...It is up to God to judge, not us.

I find it amazing that Christians are the biggest judges and hypocrits. I am a Christian but I try to not judge. Christ himself did not judge so why do we as Christians? Because someone is gay, or a murderer or a thief still does not give us the right to judge them. Christ didn't and if we want to be Christlike in nature, then we need to quit being so hypocritical and love all humans....not just some but all.....and pray that the souls find Grace in our Heavenly Father's eyes.

 

No where in the Bible does it say that when someone passes from this life do they go to Heaven or Hell...where does it say that? They enter a realm where Christ Himself visited. We need to pray for these souls.

Sep 28, 2011 7:50 PM Guest Carol  says:
I find it curious that a large population in Hollywood, and even a large portion of California, for that matter, has the same view that Roger does.  I know Kirk Cameron and Ray Comfort try to counteract it in their Living Waters ministry in that area.  I would love to investigate further why so many in that Hollywood culture feel the same way.
Sep 28, 2011 8:15 PM Guest Mary Alice M.  says:

I am praying that God will be merciful and reveal Himself to Mr. Ebert in such a way that he will see Him as He is before it is too late.  I never understand why people do not ask themselves, "What if I'm wrong?"  I'm praying for his salvation.

Sep 28, 2011 8:23 PM Guest Sandy K.  says:
I did not read 100% of the comments, someone may have already said this.  First and formost, yes it is extremely sad to see a person walk away from Christ, their only hope for eternal salvation.  After feeling that realization, then I am struck with the thought -- how could someone spend their time in a career that demanded all the viewing of anti-faith material, and come out having faith themseves?  Yes bitterly sad, but not the least bit shocking.  As humans, we become what we 'behold'.  What a lesson is here!
Sep 28, 2011 8:26 PM Guest Tim  says:

Good note, Jim, about making a living judging films, yet him not believing in a divine judge about life itself... (did our hearts not burn within us?)

 

"Nevertheless when it shall turn to the Lord, the vail shall be taken away." (2 Cor 3:16)

I believe Paul was talking about Jews there, but firsthand I know secular-human-gnostic has a similar vail.

Note to us all about involvements with /prayer for unsaved loved ones. They CAN'T get it yet, keep that in mind. Without Christ, they won't, they can't get it.

The NAME of Jesus and the HOLY GHOST INSIDE us makes that all-important change of heart.

 

I know things get rough sometimes even among Christian believers.The bible warns us all about trouble in church (2Peter2:1-3, Jude 3-16)... good reason for us all to stick to the bible and be wise and kind with each other.

Sep 28, 2011 8:26 PM Guest Meghan M.  says:

Whether I beleive in gravity or not, I will remain stuck to the earth by it.  I can "not believe" and jump off a cliff (convinced that's okay by my unbelief) but I will quickly discover the truth that gravity exists - I won't fly just because *I* don't believe in gravity.  God is like that. Whether Mr. Ebert recognizes his childhood faith and his Creator or not, Mr. Ebert, like every other child of God, WILL live forever (but, I suspect that without conversion he's not going to like the location).  I will pray that, before his death (even on his deathbed sucking that last breath), God will remind him how much He loves him and Mr. Ebert will reconvert to his Catholic Faith.  It's not over until that last breath - Jesus will still receive him at the last possible second and all we can do is pray for him to soften enough for Jesus to be allowed to save him.

Sep 28, 2011 8:28 PM Guest Phil L.  says:
Jim, this was very difficult for me to read.  My wife, who is intent on divorcing, is every bit the secular humanist Mr. Ebert appears to be.  Our two daughters are not saved either.  I'm reminded of Matthew 13:57, “Only in his hometown and in his own house is a prophet without honor” (NIV 1984).  I pray for all lost souls, espeically those closest to me.  I will raise Mr. Ebert up in prayer too.
Sep 28, 2011 8:11 PM Guest Sally  says in response to Alta M.:

Alta, your questions are valid and thought-provoking.  I don't profess to be an expert on this quite complex subject; I will leave that distinction to others who have spent much more time researching and examining.  However, I do know that my God is a God who does not condone or ordain evil, even for the purpose of redemptive work; rather, he allows free choice which includes the choice to do evil.  However, he is fully able to bring about redemption in spite of the evil that is done.

The children who are brutally abused is a difficult case; but we must put this in perspective.  As terrible as their fate may be, our life times are a mere drop in the ocean of eternity.  And just because a person exercising free will commits atrocities, that does not mean that our creator is responsible.  Yes, he could have chosen to create a world where he controlled everything; but he didn't.  He allows us an amazing amount of freedom to make our own choices, both good and bad.  Yet he does have a plan for the lives of all who by the end of their short time on earth, believe and trust in him.

This is far from a comprehensive answer to your comment; but these are my thoughts.

Sep 28, 2011 8:13 PM Guest Marlena  says in response to Alta M.:
To Alta M.,  I believe the suffering you are observing that seems random is the hopelessness of sin in the world.  The Bible says that the devil comes to steal, kill and destroy.  That is what this world does to us, some more than others I admit.  So I agree the suffering drives people to despair but that is why the gospel is such Good News.  It brings redemption and renewal where sin has brought us down.  I think you need to stop focusing on the reason for suffering and focus on Christ our hope who came to bring us life and that more abundantly.
Sep 28, 2011 8:32 PM Guest Gary S.  says:
I like your columns and the thought provoking approach.  I've also enjoyed Ebert's perspective on movies but didn't realize the roots of it. I've met few real atheists, most quick shift to agnosticism.  But there are a few who seem sure that there is nothing out there beyond their own experience and knowledge--sounds rather arrogant put that way. One more thing to add to the file--the explanation of Protagoras' famous quote has another possible interpretation i.e.  Man is a measurer, not the one who decides value and worth but rather one who is always trying to assess (or measure) what he encounters. 
Sep 28, 2011 8:19 PM Guest Sharon  says in response to Alta M.:

Alta,

I'm not Mr. Daly and I won't place myself in the seat of experts on spiritual matters. I am just a child of God who has been through just a little suffering. So I humbly offer my opinion on your question. Others may answer better but I also know, the question won't be thoroughly answered until we sit at Jesus' feet. Nowhere in Scripture do I see where God said our suffering is redemptive. His suffering and death alone brought redemption. The suffering of the world does not offer salvation. He does say that we will suffer tribulation in this world. Our rejoicing in the midst of suffering is only because He has overcome the world. In other words, our victory over suffering will be when we leave this world behind. Life on this earth is hard and many suffer horribly. Suffering is a direct result of mankind's sin, not necessarily of those who've suffered. Mankind's self will has created a world in which suffering exists. The only hope of the world is that the suffering will cause many of us to turn to Him for help. Then, we simply trust Him to take care of the rest. This world is not just. This world can hold unspeakable evil and pain. Innocence is not an escape from these horrors. This is why Christians should be shouting to the world that Christ paid the debt for sin and offers a life in eternity with Him, free from suffering. My heart breaks for the hurting. Despite the atrocities, I can rest in His presence and know that He sees and cares and is acting in ways I do not see. I must simply trust Him and be obedient when He calls me to aid in some small way. I hope this helps in some way.

Sep 28, 2011 8:21 PM Guest Charles H.  says:
There is hope for Roger Ebert. There is an orthodox Christian doctrine, not nearly as popular today as it was during the earliest Church era before Constantine, but one that is today finding its way back into the mainstream of more and more Christian minds and hearts concerning the next life. After Jesus returns to the earth as Emanuel, God with us, with his saints resurrected from their graves, who will reign with him on the earth for a thousand years, Revelation 20 tells us in verse 5 that the rest of the dead who were not first resurrected also finally will come back to life. Of these folks, verse 12 tells us that one of the books to be opened will be the book of life and there will be names written in that book. There is a striking difference between those in the first resurrection and those that come back to life later whose names are in the book of life -- the second group will have missed out on the opportunity to be with Jesus for a thousand years, reigning with him. Yet they too will live. For those of us Christians who believe these easy-to-understand words in Revelation, it is not a stretch of human reasoning to hope that many who are resurrected back to life at the later date will see not only Christ, but also a fabulous and loving world, on this planet, that has prospered during a thousand year period without the influence of Satan and thoroughly under the influence and loving authority of our gracious Savior and King, and his previously resurrected saints. My hope is that for people like Roger, should they never come around to knowing Jesus in this life, they will yet have that opportunity when the "rest of the dead lived not again till the thousand years were finished." If this is new to anyone here, it is not new to Christianity. Many Christians of the early church believed in John's words about the 1st resurrection and the time, 1,000 years later, when the rest come back to life, and that in the book of life will be found the names of many people in that second group. We cannot make judgments on who those people are or aren't -- that's God's call, but we can sure hope. I hope, and pray, that Roger and others like him, should they be among those who come back to life after the thousand years, will respond to what they see with a new understanding about faith, eternal life, and the love of God and his son Jesus. Roger is not the only one who cannot believe without seeing. Jesus graciously showed the nail holes in his hands to Thomas who could not believe without seeing. How many millions of people are like Thomas -- know about Jesus but cannot not believe without seeing? Will Jesus be as gracious to Roger Ebert and all the others when they meet Christ at that time in the future as he was gracious to Thomas who could not believe without seeing? Jesus' track record is of undeserved graciousness to all. Even those who literally drove the nails into his hands. So there is hope for Roger Ebert.
Sep 28, 2011 8:24 PM Guest Michelle  says in response to Dan:

Dan,

 

Thank you for sharing your experience.  You say you can never again say, "I'm not afraid to die."  Have you come to faith in Jesus Christ?  I assume so but you don't say in your response.  If you have put your faith in Christ alone, do you still fear death?

Sep 28, 2011 8:26 PM Guest Terry  says:
One only has to consider the Words in Romans 1:18-23 to understand Mr Ebert's position.  It is the ultimate of denial, and I think it is because to accept the fact that God is a Holy Being to be reckoned with and will ultimately be faced means that people have to deal with that in some way.  The Scripture says clearly that "For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them."  This says there is something innate in every human being that says we're eternal beings and there IS a God, but it's suppressed in unrighteousness.  It's the ultimate in foolish denial.  The Lord Himself said that "many" will choose the wide path.  I guess Mr Ebert is one who is making his choice.
Sep 28, 2011 8:47 PM Guest Bill H.  says in response to Dan:
Dan, it seems to me as if you failed to apprehend the life offered you after the accident. God had proven Himself to you but you never mentioned seeking Him and learning of his love and grace.
Sep 28, 2011 8:32 PM Guest Amber k  says in response to Alta M.:

Fellow saint,

There is one thing you have stated but overlooked. You used the word "innocent" when describing a child. If the Word of God is true, then all men sinned in Adam, and all men are sinners. We are not sinners because we sin, but sin because we are sinners. This child was born with a sin nature that is in rebellion to God. We all are born with this. It is God alone who reaches out and draws people to Him with His irresistable grace. While no one would argue that this child deserves not to be afflicted, we need to remember that all of us deserve hell. Without God's infinite mercy we would all go there. Like you I am deeply affected by the suffering of anyone at the hands of another. In that suffering, God is present. He is not standing by, hands behind His back, watching but unable to step in. He does what is most honoring to Himself, He is there. He is working, whether we see it or make sense of it or not. Just because we don't find answers doesn't mean they don't exist, only that our Creator has withheld them. Suffering is always redemptive in nature because it works in us to conform us to the image of His precious Son. We cannot be sanctified, purified, without first feeling the heat of the fire that burns from us the dross of our sins. As long as there is sin, there will be suffering. It is more about how we handle the affliction, what it does within us, how we are transformed by it than why it occurs. God never leaves or forsakes His Own, He cannot, it would go against His very Word. Please remember to look not to the suffering and focus on it, but look to the One who suffered for our sakes to purchase our redemption. Look how He was led like a lamb before His shearers, silent, obedient. And likewise do the same.

Sep 28, 2011 8:37 PM Guest Lyn  says:

Yes, it is an interesting article about Mr. Ebert, and it is very sad that he does not believe in salvation through Jesus. However, it's not only a famous man who does not believe, it's some of our neighbors, families, and friends who also do not believe in Christ and need our prayers. We may not be able to sit down with Mr. Ebert and share our faith, but we can with those God has placed in our lives. May this article remind us to pray for those in Hollywood and open our lips to share our faith with those in our personal lives.

Sep 29, 2011 5:42 AM Guest larry  says:

typical!!!

Sep 28, 2011 8:44 PM Guest Vicki  says in response to Russell:

Russell, If you're right and Jesus is God who spoke the truth, that doesn't mean that Ebert will burn in hell.  That is not something that Jesus ever said.

Sep 28, 2011 9:05 PM Guest Karla  says:
How sad that Roger Ebert apparently does not believe in God.  While I am a Christian, at least I believe I am, I can almost understand why some people hold the views he does.  Sadly, among Christians, there are so many different views as to what being a Christian really is.  It runs the gamut from so called "Lordship salvation" by those who oppose salvation by works to "Easy Believe-ism" by those who are opposed to faith alone in Christ alone.  It's no wonder so many are confused.  Personally, I believe Christ died in my place to suffer the penalty I deserved for my sin and rose from the dead for my justification and when I accept His payment for me and believe that He went to the cross for me, I am saved and a child of God--"Nothing in my hand I bring-simply to the cross I cling". My prayer is that Roger and others like him come to the place where they, too, can accept what Christ did for them.
Sep 28, 2011 9:09 PM Guest Michelle  says in response to Alta M.:

Alta M.

 

My heart hears what you are saying and senses your search for Truth.  Jesus said He is the "way, the truth and the life".  Jesus is the word made flesh.  The word of God says human suffering is the result of sin.  All of us are born with sin and our hearts are evil.  The prophet Jeremiah said our hearts are desperately wicked.  God himself said he would replace our hearts of stone with hearts of flesh.  Matthew 15:19 says, "For from the heart come evil thoughts, murder, adultery all other sexual immorality, theft, lying and slander."  Sin destroyed God's perfect creation as recorded in Genesis.  It is the sin nature we are all born with that prompts our rebellious acts from a tender age when we make our first choice to disobey.  We are all doomed to this hopelessness BUT FOR GOD.  God's heart response is shown through Jesus' response when he grieves over Jeruselem.  Jesus said, "How often I have wanted to gather your children together as a hen protects her chicks beneath her wings, but you wouldn't let me.  And now look, your house is left to you, empty and desolate."  Our world is most definately empty and desolate of hope BUT FOR GOD AND HIS LOVE.  I don't know how God does it but I have personally experienced God's goodness in the midst of suffering.  I have looked back over painful years where I asked the same questions you pose above and can confidently say, God is greater than the circumstances.  God is faithful. God does not change.  Only God can bring good from pain, trial & suffering.  Suffering helps us comfort others who are sufferig.  Suffering provides an opportunity to encourage others.  Trials help develop patience.  I hope this helps you as you search for God's heart.

 

"And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to His purpose."  Romans 8:28

Sep 29, 2011 5:44 AM Guest Dave  says:

I have to first admit that Focus has lost focus with me over the last few years. But with this blog Daly grabbed my attention by hitting head-on one of the greater cultural issues of our time. So many people believe that this world is it - that there is no hereafter - but this commentary on the life of a commentator is more than I expected.

 

This is one of the better blog posts from Jim Daly that I've read in a while. He and the Focus Team deftly drove the point home, without dancing around the hard-hitting points, that Secular Humanism stands in stark contrast with a Christian Worldview.

 

Bring us more of this, Focus, and you'll grab and hold my attention again.

 

This blog gets Two Thumbs Up!!!

Sep 28, 2011 9:13 PM Guest Diane  says:
The Bible says that God has created the knowledge of the Creator in each and every one of us.  It's sad so see someone so gifted and thoughtful like Roger, that hasn't been able to grasp that truth.  The beauty of our Lord, is that He created us with freedom of choice.  What kind of God would He be if he forced us to believe in Him, or to love Him?  He loves us so much that He desires our love to be our choice.  Recently studying Acts, I'm learning more about the power that God has for us through His gift of the Holy Spirit.  There were those in the room with the Apostles that didn't understand the speaking in tongues in their own languages, but accused the Apostles of drinking to much wine.  In every age, there have been people that do not even recognize their Savior when He speaks to them through others' kindness, forgiveness, love and prayer.  But, we do not know who those people will be, so we need to continue praying for them all.  What a blessing if we will also see them among God's faithful followers!  That would just even more prove God's power to work through us as believers in Christ.  There's a great quote by C.S. Lewis in "Mere Christianity" - When you have reached your own room, be kind to those who have chosen different doors and to those who are still in the hall.  If they are wrong they need your prayers all the more; and if they are your enemies, then you are under orders to pray for them.  That is one of the rules common to the whole house.
Sep 29, 2011 4:35 PM Guest Rick H  says:

There is much value in philosophical discussions, esp when trying to understand how to reconcile a loving God with a fallen world - for that there are wonderful books by people like Ravi Zacharias, Lee Strobel, William Lane Craig, and countless others. However, what is available to us today is objective data that people are unaware of. God is performing miracles of healing all over the world and in certain places in the U.S., and it is both available to see in person and on video. Check out for example the testimonies on Global Awakening's site and that of Bethel Church. I have actually been to 4 countries with Global Awakening, and seen thousands of people healed in the name of Jesus of all kinds of chronic pain, and also personally witnessed at arm's length a blind eye opened, a deaf ear opened, a tumor vanish, a leg restored that couldn't bend for 2 years, a man healed of lung trouble so severe that he couldn't walk under his own power or speak, and many similar healings happening from prayers of others nearby, and many other healings. Don't believe my words, go see it for yourself. Check out the testimonies available on the web. Then talk to people like Mr. Ebert, who think religion is a matter of what one believes in their own mind. No, there is absolute truth and hard data, and the medical profession is starting to get involved. See the recent studies, “Scientific Study of Healing at Iris Ministries Shows Proximity Key to Success of Healing Prayer,” News Release : Aug 6, 2010 and corresponding book, Global Pentecostal and Charismatic Healing, by Candy Gunther Brown, 2011. There are also some conferences held in locations all over the US where you can see some of these things , e.g. see Global Awakening or Bill Johnson's dite for itineraries. (They often partner on things – Bethel has a very powerful healing prayer ministry, especially re cancers, including healing prayer by Skype.) Randy Clark and Bill Johnson are the pastors behind Global Awakening and Bethel church, but numerous others frequently see miraculous healings. Other names for example are Heidi and Rolland Baker, Ian Andrews, John and Carol Arnott, Francis MacNutt, Cal Pierce, Che Ahn, Leif Hetland, Will Hart, Georgian Banov, Kris Vallotton, Mahesh and Bonnie Chavda, Phillip Mantofa, Marc Dupont, Mike and Cherrie Kaylor, Benny Hinn, Reinhard Bonnke, etc.  Theology is great, but I am actually a scientist and even people like me can be convinced by thousands of people healed e.g. wherever Global Awakening goes, with several tens of the dramatic healings I am talking about on every trip. Research and find the data, see it with your own eyes, tell others, and expect it to become common knowledge because in the connected world we live in it has to, sooner or later.  Open your heart to what God is doing - even many Christians refuse to believe it. That is going to change, hopefully sooner rather than later. Accept His love, and share it! Blessings to you!

Sep 29, 2011 5:45 AM Guest Marilyn  says:

Death is the ultimate wake-up call.  We all can say words, hollow words, like Mr. Ebert.  They don't mean a thing when you are taking your last breath.  I had rather count on Jesus than words about  the hope of nothingness.

Sep 28, 2011 9:26 PM Guest Phil  says in response to Russell:

If he is right, then I mind being wrong.  If he is right, I should not mind or care about anything.  But we do care, and even as he judges film, we judge ourselves and our world.  We do think, we do feel, we do act, with our minds and wills.  All of this and all of what is point clearly to the God of the Bible who is the creator in his image.

 

Let us not speak of not minding if he would be right.  That is the wrong message for our world.

Sep 28, 2011 9:33 PM Guest Kathy  says:
I have a firm belief that there is a life after death. For the Christian, heaven. For the unbeliever, eternal punishment.  I am a Christian and I hold on to that hope of being with my Creator in eternity.  If Mr. Ebert is right that it doesn't matter after this life, then that is okay, but if I'm right and he is wrong, then he has a BIG problem.
Sep 29, 2011 5:45 AM Guest Paul  says in response to Alta M.:

Alta M,

 

Let me start off by saying that you are not alone in trying to comprehend the atrocities that unfold around us every day.  We see it in the news, hear about it from friends and sadly in some cases even experience these things ourselves.  There is something we should however never forget.  We as people with a free, God given will, choose these things.  God has given us the ablity to choose good or choose evil.  Otherwise we are just mindless robots only doing good. Given this choice, we have turned from God and given ourselves over to the temptations and lies of Satan.  People are not "basically" good. People are evil precisely because they do not follow and obey their Creator.  But, "Where is God when these things happen?"  "Why is God not intervening?" you ask. I can assure you that God is fully aware and fully prepared to exact a perfect and unwaivering judgement in His timeframe, not ours.  For anyone to suggest that God is not "doing things the right way" or that they could "do it better if they were in charge" is to deny God's Sovereignty and rob Him of the Glory He deserves.  But what about cancer, disease and other such horrors?  Did we choose these?  Maybe not direcctly but as soon as we chose to turn from God, death entered the world. These things are a direct result of our fall.  So while we may not have directly chosen to have cancer, disease, etc these things are certainly a result of our rejection of God's perfect protection.  We can look forward to a time when all this will be corrected.  We can also recognize that in many cases even with man's evil intentions, God can and has intervened and used these experiences to bring about good things.  Some are driven to turn from evil and move toward Christ.  Whatever the case may be, I promise you that every sin is perfectly reconciled in God's perfect timing.  We cannot comprehend this but we must as followers of Christ accept it. It is not easy, but then God never said it would be.  Trusting God is hard and that is what seperates us as believers from the rest of this fallen world.

Sep 29, 2011 5:46 AM Guest Edna  says:
  1. I would say to Mr. Ebert that you really should re-assess your faith in your own opinion because Satan and his demons are NOT atheists, and they are NOT agnostics...and they tremble. Why do they tremble Mr. Ebert? As it has been said before, Jesus Christ was ONE of these three:  Liar, Lunatic, or Lord. There are NO other possibilities. I say Jesus Christ is Lord. If you are right you have lost nothing. If I am right you have lost everything.
Sep 28, 2011 10:16 PM Guest Kristine  says:
Well said.
Sep 28, 2011 10:54 PM Guest Scott  says:

I met Mr. Ebert many years ago, and wondered about his overall health because he didn't look very healthy at that time. I am sad to hear that his jaw had to be removed because of thyroid cancer - I will be praying for him...

Sep 28, 2011 11:40 PM Guest Rhuebekah  says in response to Alta M.:
Do you think that maybe the pain and terrible things you mention are caused by sin.  Not saying if something bad is happening to you it is b/c of your personal sin against God but someone else's sin will effect another.  Like a husband cheating on a wife causes intense pain for the wife.  Someone's sick sinful mind will lead to pain against an innocent child?  I find this sad as you do especially child slavery which breaks my heart and brings me to tears..  I just think sin is the reason why the world is so sad and broken. God gave us free will which means we have the choice to hurt others or to love others.
Sep 29, 2011 5:47 AM Guest Donna  says in response to Alta M.:

Alta,

 

We are not to question God...the poor will always be with us, the sick, dying...we are not to ask God why because He is in control.  Someday, on the other side, it will all be explained to us and we will no longer have to ask why.  The important thing is your questioning seems to stand between you and a salvation belief in God.  Roger E. will someday have his questions answered, but for you, not knowing when you will die, life is entirely too short to spend it questioning.  Accept the peace and love He offers you, snuggle into His loving outstretched arms, and rest assured your questions will be answered someday.  Don't let questions stand between you and heaven.

Sep 29, 2011 12:39 AM Guest Tim  says in response to Dan:

Amen brother ... there is sub-thread among some of these comments about the value and meaning of suffering, and the reasons God might allow "innocent" humans to experience suffering...some are talking about general impressions seen in mainstream media, not individual stories accounting for the God factor in each life; "the rest of the story".

 

It sounds like you are saying you had a vision and you acted more wisely since God gave that to you.

"The fear of the LORD is a fountain of life, to depart from the snares of death." (Prov 14:27)

"Let not your heart be troubled: ye believe in God, believe also in me." (John 14:1, Jesus speaking)

Sep 29, 2011 5:47 AM Guest Al  says in response to Tori:
Life presents too many "coincidences" for there NOT to be a God.  I am sad to consider that Mr. Ebert believes in nothingness after death.  If we know that life is not accidental, but planned, how can we believe this is all there is?  I can't.  I look forward to death, and being with Jesus.
Sep 29, 2011 1:23 AM Guest Tim  says in response to Alta M.:

There was a discussion last Sunday about a similar topic... I heard this from a few older saints ...

 

We don't know now the total meaning, the exact value of each suffering...

BUT we do know God is watching each of OUR RESPONSES.

"...now we see through a glass darkly..." (from 1 Corinthians 13:12)

 

Throughout Christian history there has been notable and amazing feats of grace by God through his people... examples we do well to follow.

During the Roman plagues, sick children (and all ages) were abandoned in dumps by fleeing families... many Christians stayed in Rome to gather and care for these. Some lost their lives. Time would fail to list all the wonderful individual efforts and stories of overcoming written in the pages of history. I know there seems moreso endless unanswered and chaos.

 

You mention conditions in Africa now; I know of several orphanages and hospitals set up by Christians in response to that. It does not fix it all, but it helps as we are able, it is a reponse.

You mention sex abuse of children; there are individuals and institutions set up by Christians (and other religions too) where found ones can endeavor and be helped in recovery; some ones rescued become future helpers of others... but the value and outcome of it all remains to be seen. I encourage you. We do well to LOOK UP, trust and act on Christ's example in the bible.

 

Consider Job.

In the middle of the story, it all seems pointless and crazy; round and round blame and excuse and retort...

but after God's presence manifests and the dialog happens between God and Job, the faithful humble sufferer places his entire existence in God's hands, and becomes blessed.

Consider Lazarus.

Desiring to be fed from scraps from the rich man's table. Dogs licking his sores. Wasting away and finally a pitiful death. And according to Jesus' account of Abraham's words, the explanation was, before death, one suffered and the other indulged... after death the indulger suffered and the sufferer was comforted. (Luke 16:19-25)

Consider Paul's statement:

"For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us." (Romans 8:18)

Consider Peter's words:

"Wherefore let them that suffer according to the will of God commit the keeping of their souls to him in well doing, as unto a faithful Creator." (1 Peter 4:19)

 

Only words, I know, .... but we're here now, like this.  We do the best we can with what we have, and trust God for a good result...

 

It might seem that God is putting a call to service on your heart ... prayerfully... ask Him about it, and go make the difference He calls you to.

(only He knows where each of us can be the best help, where we "fit")

Sep 29, 2011 5:06 AM Guest Marcia  says:
You have brought Mr. Ebert's "heart" condition to our attention.  Now he has many people praying for him that otherwise would not have.  There is hope through the power of prayer and God's intervening grace.
Sep 29, 2011 5:48 AM Guest Sue  says in response to Russell:
Whoever believes in Jesus is not condemned, but whoever does NOT believe stands condemned already because he has not believed in the name of God's one and only Son.  John 3:18   And   Jesus is THE WAY, THE TRUTH, and THE LIFE....  John 14:6  and  all things were made through Jesus and must therefore return through him.   Until God gives you Faith to Believe, you will never understand the things of God... Praying for the Lost.... and thanking our Holy and Righteous Judge for saving me and giving me new life! Amen
Sep 29, 2011 6:05 AM Guest Sohaila  says:
What are we so afraid of. To be rejected? Life is made of choices we either choose to love or hate; like or dislike. We try to make it so hard. Yet, every second of our day is made with us choosing one or the other. When we establish that one helps us we learn to clink to it, if we are afraid we reject it yet tip toe right back into it. Mr. Ebert has "Love" and he relies on it, that is why he is still here being a testimony of that "Love"; yes,  that "Love" that resides in him. HE MAY NOT ACKNOWLEDGE IT with the same name we as christians do but is there. I strongly believe that when he takes his last breath he will do it with a smile on his face.
Sep 29, 2011 6:10 AM Guest gbrc  says in response to Don K:

Don K:

 

You state: "To GBRC: Regarding your statement 'the grace of his baptism...save him'.  A ritual does not save anyone, especiallly words spoken over an unknowing infant with some water splashed on. God does not teach that and it is quite dangerous to trust such a concept. Just like everyone else, Roger Ebert and I must choose to excercise faith in Jesus Christ and receive his grace and forgiveness for our sin."

 

which is in response to my original post: "May the grace of his baptism draw Mr. Ebert back to the faith of his youth.  God's indelible seal is on Mr. Ebert's soul.  Let's pray that he responds to the Lord's calling and offer of unfathomable Divine Mercy."

 

I presume that you did not purposely misquote me, but you may want to cut and paste in the future to avoid such missteps.  Nowhere do I use the word "save," and neither Jim Daly nor I speak of infant baptism.  Rather, I speak of the grace imparted upon Mr. Ebert at his baptism and my prayer that he responds to that grace and the Lord's calling.

 

Baptism is, in fact, a ritual that involves spoken words -- specifically, "I baptize you in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit," words and a mandate given to us directly from the Lord Jesus, Himself -- and water, a ritual that imparts the saving grace of God upon the baptized.

 

If you are assuming that Mr. Ebert was baptized as infant simply because Mr. Daly told us that he was raised as a Catholic, then you may want to reconsider your logic and the veracity of your statements.  The subject of infant baptism is a discussion for another venue, but I hope that you are not proclaiming that Mr. Ebert's baptism was invalid because you assume that he was an infant at the time or, worse, simply because it was a Catholic baptism.

Sep 29, 2011 6:24 AM Guest Becky  says:
Good Grief Robert Ebert watched to many movies!
Sep 29, 2011 6:26 AM Guest Sarah  says:
So thankful for the purpose that Jesus brings to life, even (especially!) the hard parts!
Sep 29, 2011 6:40 AM Guest Chris C  says:
Sorry Roger...two thumbs down.   Although Love, God's Love, is a Truth we can only grasp the hem of, it proves that our merciful God allows us to accept or reject His offer of love through the merits of His Son.   Christianity extends beyond a simple relationship for in its fulfulled purpose it is a reunion with community and a triune God.   Incorruptible life must be understood in the capacity and promise of that sole object, Jesus.   Being raised Catholic myself, it grieves me that Roger has turned his back on the intimacy of the Truth.  However, I will continue to pray in the merciful time he has left to seek first God's indestructible Love.
Sep 29, 2011 6:47 AM Guest katherine s.  says in response to Russell:
well put !!!
Sep 29, 2011 6:58 AM Guest katherine s.  says:
aren't we thankful as believers we can say....." I know whom I have believed, and am are persuaded that His able to keep that which I've commited unto Him against that day "....Thank you Lord for you mercies they are new every morning " Great is Thy Faithfulness Lord unto me "
Sep 29, 2011 7:11 AM Guest Chris C  says in response to Alta M.:
Alta M., thank you for a realistic view and your honesty.  It is not good enough to "cut and paste" scripture to heal a problem since that concept is abhored in the epistle of St. James.  The question is why a loving, merciful God permits the atrocities you speak of along of others you and I are blind to.  Sadly, types of confusing Christianity concentrate only on a personal relationship.  This is a partial Gospel...dare I say 'another' Gospel.  For we are not only called to the ultimate worship of God's gift of His love in Jesus (which doesn't take much) BUT we are called to Love, that is works of Love, that includes social justice, alms giving, and protection in regards to our neighbor in need.  Christianity is NOT found in a single 'sinner's prayer' but revealed in our growing awareness of the beatitudes.  Understand and seek the message of St. James, faith and works, and Col 1:24 will finally make sense to you.  Peace my friend.
Sep 29, 2011 7:20 AM Guest Jimi  says in response to Alta M.:
Alta, you should read "The Holiness of God" by R.C. Sproul. It will not remove your questions it will simply alter your perception of the God we serve and that will, in turn, alter the way you feel these questions should be answered. In this day and age we tend to preach only about a God of love which then leaves questions much like yours screaming for answers. It is only when we begin to look at God's holiness and what that means that we can understand better the pains of this world and realize that these injustices will be met with God's justice and wrath. Anyway...this book really helped me and I think you would really benefit from it as well in your searching and journey to know Him better. May God bless you and reveal Himself to you that you may come to a place of utter dependance upon Him.
Sep 29, 2011 7:31 AM Guest Rick B.  says:
One of my co-workers was like Mr. Ebert in both beliefs and disease (cancer).  When he died, his wife did not even have a funeral for him.  His body was simply cremated "and that was that".  It struck me as so odd, that his death was simply cleaned up, like taking out the trash.  What a shallow, empty view of humanity that is!  Its no wonder that people operating under that worldview were responsible for killing almost 100 million people in the 20th century; Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and Pol Pot among the worst.  As Christians, we must not lose sight that this worldview is not simply "lost", but that it is evil.  Judge a tree by its fruits.
Sep 29, 2011 7:34 AM Guest Sherry  says in response to Alta M.:

We live in a fallen world.  Suffering is a result of that.  When God created the world, he created it perfectly...there would be no suffering.  But He also gave man a free will.  Adam chose to disobey God and sin entered the world.  At that moment, suffering began.  God is not surprised, nor is he sitting back wringing his hands in distress at the current state of the world. I have no doubt He is saddened by it, but He also expects those of us who do believe to minister to those who are suffering; to speak His words of peace and comfort to those who are hurting.  We may not be able to help everyone, but we must do what we can for those we can.  We will not have the answers in this life but we have to trust in the One wno has perfect knowedge.  "And the peace of God, which passes all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus." (Phil. 4.7) 

Sep 29, 2011 7:41 AM Guest Karen G.  says:
Even tho I didn't officially become a Christian until I was 32, I always believed in God. The world is too complex. Our bodies are too complex to believe that they could happen by accident or random occurrence. Mr. Eibert, you should be thanking God that you are alive and I pray that you will come to a knowledge of Jesus Christ before you do pass from this Earth. You have been given the precious gift of time to research, question, search for the truth. Use it wisely Mr. Eibert. It is written-a fool says in his heart there is no God-Psalm 53:1. Be wise and learn while there is still time.
Sep 29, 2011 7:37 AM Guest Dan W  says:
To me, this show how important our testimony is. Living a true, pure, and consistant life is vital to being a constant reflection of Christ. Those who have not the Spirit know not the Spirit. And in turn (as in the case of Mr. Ebert) likely don't even believe the Spirit exists, yet we have Him living within us! When others see that there really is something else there, they're forced to either believe or come up with more excuses to deny God's very existance. This is why hypocrisy can be such a fatality to those concidering any sort of faith in God. Unfortunately, we can't make the decision for anyone else, but we can humbly strive to be a constant, consistant, and never wavering follower (and example) of Christ Himself! Our faith should always be TRUE and always be NOW!
Sep 29, 2011 7:38 AM Guest Trish  says:
The most bizarre conclusion about the afterlife I know of is summed up in Mr. Ebert's statement, "All depends on what is believed in." Secular humanism is a belief system so arrogant and self centered as to conlcude that God and eternity is whatever I decide it is.  "I have no desire to live forever", therefore, I will not. What in Science or life has led these people to such faulty logic? Over what on this side of death has man total control over? Gravity, aging, death itself.  By his logic he should be able to say, "I don't believe I am sick therefore I am not." Life is all about absolutes that we cannot change - only seek to understand and embrace. Truth is Jesus - believe it or not, it is so.
Sep 29, 2011 8:18 AM Guest Jennifer  says:

It's evident Man has no conscience about the Creator, until the Spirit awakens them to his beauty and Love.  This is why it's so important for parents to love, nurture and teach their children about God and his love for them while they are still infants, and receive forgiveness of sins through Jesus Christ and be reconciled to God.  Thankyou Focus on the Family, as you continue in excellency of Spirit awakening us to our roles as parents!  We know that if anyone has faith even as small as a mustard seed, Jesus said he can move mountains.  We know light is a gift from God, its warmth, its sunshine.  Rain is a gift from God, it waters, and brings life.  Certainly God cares deeply for his creation, of which Mr. Ebert is included in God's care. God gives him air to breathe every day.  I pray a God thought would come to his mind, and take root of his amazing love for him personally! I pray all other fiery darts, of doubt, unbelief, and lies would be silented.  I pray in the name above all names, Jesus Christ our Lord. Thanks for sharing the article, and as creation itself cries out, may we also be strenghthened to go out and share God's great love for people!

Sep 29, 2011 8:22 AM Guest Mickey  says:
I believe that God is bestowing His Mercy upon Mr Ebert giving him more time to realize his mistake and become a Testimony if he Accepts Jesus before it's too late! He should not Frustrate the Grace of God. 
Sep 29, 2011 8:42 AM Guest Susan L.  says:
My heart is very heavy after reading this article.   There is nothing sadder than knowing what Christ went through on the cross even for those He know would deny Him.  There is a peace and a joy just knowin the Savior and this man has spend all those years without these attributes.  I feel sorry for this individual, he will spend the rest his eternity in the darkest pit of hell.  Christ when too such a brutal cross so that we don't have to.
Sep 29, 2011 8:33 AM Guest Dave  says in response to Alta M.:

Hi Alta M.

Thanks so much for sharing your struggle.  God doesn't make sense to us.  I am the clay and He is the glorious Potter.  I look to Him to use me for His purpose which is hard to do.  It's hard to see and comprehend when things don't make sense especially suffering.  Jesus died and redeemed the whole world so why this pain?!  I have found three answers in Scripture.  One is original sin.  The world is corrupt.  My car rusts and breaks.  People let me down and I let them down.  Second is punishment.  God says he will punish us like sons He loves.  Parenting today has gotten so far away from this and the ugly word "consequences" because it's hard to discipline.  Instead people think they have to be their child's buddy.  Discipline done in a loving and corrective way is God-pleasing.  So He disciplines me at times too.  It's not fun but I have to be ok with that.  It helps me take a look at what I did wrong.  The prodigal son had to be reduced to feeding pigs before he got it and went back to the Father in repentance.  The Father then ran to Him in forgiveness. (Luke 15).  Third is refining by fire like silver.  The clothes in the washer get pretty beat up before it comes out clean.  Yes we are washed clean by Jesus blood and His grace takes our sins away.  At the same time, God's Word talks about refining.  Walking with Christ as His disciple is not a walk in the park.  It's not popular.  It's not easy.  My comfort is placing myself in His hands with His Word to St. Paul - My Grace is sufficient for you.  I pray this is not received as a platitude because through the pain and suffering God has raised up some pretty incredible people to serve Him and others.  I thank God that He uses me even in a small way to do the same.  God's peace, blessing and joy in Jesus.

Sep 29, 2011 8:45 AM Guest Dale B.  says:

I know what you mean. I've encountered this same thing in some.  ALso, some christians have some of this secular humanist thinking mixed in. They water down christianity, they are mis-guided.                                             

Sep 29, 2011 8:45 AM Guest Nell  says in response to Jamie:
Well said.  I have friends and acquaintances who claim they believe no absolute truth exists, but I've never met a anyone who lives according to that credo.  They make choices continually based on their perceptions of good or evil, while at the same time claiming that good and evil do not exist.   I'm so sorry for Mr. Ebert.  He will find that his soul is indeed eternal.  Life is not like the movies.  Truth cannot be found in them.
Sep 29, 2011 9:19 AM Guest Damian M.  says:
There is much more to scriptures than the bible translations out there. Try reading the entire bible over and over, all the while asking God for His understanding. It is a wonderful thing when you let go of all the ideas man has put in our heads about who and what God is, and the Holy spirit brings us to Gods rest.
Sep 29, 2011 9:16 AM Guest Gordon  says:
Whatever you believe the truth to be about life after death, there is an amount of faith necessary to uphold that belief because you can't know the truth about it until you actually die. Ebert should check out the history of near-death experiences of people within the past twenty-five years that have come to the brink of death. Today's medical technology has made this possible. People have seen BOTH SIDES of the situation, heaven and hell.
Sep 29, 2011 9:24 AM Guest Larry B.  says in response to Dale W.:

Well stated Dale W. --- I wonder if anyone qestioned Protagoras as to whether man is the measure of all things. I guess he knows now.

 

Larry B.

Sep 29, 2011 9:27 AM Guest Gordon  says in response to Alta M.:

Dear Alta,

 

Don't you know that Jesus died on the cross for you? Personally. He did that for you, Alta! If you were the only human being on the planet that needed salvation, He still would have done that for you.

 

The imperfections, sin, death, pain and suffering, came into the world through the hands of Adam and Eve who reblled in the Garden of Eden. Before that, they walked and talked with God on a regular basis. They were holy, until they rebelled.

 

Accept His love for you today. Have you prayed the sinner's prayer? Sounds like you probably have but recognize His payment for your sin. Not one of us are perfect, all have sinned, even you. So accept His ultimate sacrifice. For you, Alta. Today.

Sep 29, 2011 2:40 PM Guest Betsy  says in response to Alta M.:
To Alta - Wow.  Thank you for sharing and for being so transparent. Your comment clearly shows that you are highly intellectual and intelligent.  Many times, it is people who have been "blessed" with your high degree of intelligence that have the most difficult time embracing saving faith in Jesus Christ.  This presents obstacles in your spiritual journey that many will never understand.  To this I say - don't give up!!!   I believe that you have been entrusted with your level of intelligence because God knew that you could handle it and you would be faithful with it.  You can use your questions and answers (or lack thereof) to reach others who like you - others that could only relate to you.  Faith is exactly what you need more of, and what I will be praying for you to receive.  Not saving faith, you have clearly accepted Jesus as your Saviour.  Faith.  Faith to accept that you will  NEVER receive the answers you are seeking and that is ok.  Faith that you don't NEED to find the answers for them to be the truth.  Faith that this life is, in fact,  preparation for eternity - whether we want it to be or not.  Faith that the horrible situations you describe happen every single day, and God sees them and does not intervene - or does He?  Faith that perhaps these atrocities are necessary for the salvation of others.  Faith that even in the midst of these situations, each and every person is given their own choice.  The choice to believe or reject.  Jesus will not return until EVERY SINGLE PERSON is given their own choice.  That, my friend, is love.  It is difficult to understand WHY this is God's plan - I am going to ask many questions when I get to heaven.  Until then, we must cling to our faith. It is faith that we need. Childlike faith. I will pray for you!!!!
Sep 29, 2011 4:25 PM Guest Greg M  says:

You are actually taking time to discuss a worldview of someone who has never professed a desire to follow Christ. You are having people comment on whether this person is, what, a believer? Or a what?

 

It just seems your time could be better spent helping believers grow as Christians. You can continue to do this and take any one's comments and use this forum for debate on how their comments are not full of the Truth. But that is not the Focus on the family I once apreciated.

Sep 29, 2011 11:46 AM Guest Sarah S  says:

Mr Daly:

 

the wicked does not seek Him, all his thoughts are, "There is no God."  Psalm 10:4

 

I find it an incredible waste of time to discuss an unbeliever's opinion. There are two kinds of people in this world: the Lost and the Saved. Now, if you were face-to-face with Roger, share your faith with him. Your time would be better spent learning more about the Lord.

 

Sincerely,

 

Sarah S

Sep 29, 2011 10:57 AM Guest Matt  says:
And while we're praying for Mr. Ebert, let's pray for Bill Maher too.
Sep 29, 2011 11:04 AM Guest Nan  says in response to Alta M.:
The type of suffering you have described is only redemptive if we are able to forgive our abusers and pray for our enemies, knowing that the same evil that exists in them, exists in us, though for complex reasons, it has been expressed quite differently.  God can heal all wounds if we give them to Him to heal.  I admit, it's a difficult cross to bear, but if we bear it, we will see the redemption.  I know of a beautiful Christian woman who has forgiven her father for raping her, impregnanting her, and forcing her to abort - twice.  The very evidence of God is her healing and her forgiveness of her father, and of being able to love her husband and children and move on to care for others.  There is a healing and a life that comes from the Spirit of God that is pure light against the backdrop of evil.  Reading Corrie Ten Boom's writings has been very helpful in understanding this and leading me toward my own path of forgivness and healing.  God bless you as you prayerfully consider these things.
Sep 29, 2011 11:11 AM Guest deb  says:
Mr Ebert's comment "I believe..." brings back to me the simple wisdom spoken by my pastor years and years ago: "You can believe anything you want, but it will never change the truth."
Sep 29, 2011 11:19 AM Guest Stacey  says in response to Alta M.:
In response to Alta, I think we all feel the same at different points in our lives.  The bottom line, I suppose, is that we live in a fallen world.  God did not create the sinfulness of our world.  We did. Every disease, abusive situation, and death is a direct result of sin.  I, too, struggle with the harshness of what, seemingly innocent, people must endure.  But think about how long the world actually existed before man messed it up by sinning. It didn't take long!  Compared to God's perfection, I guess none of us deserve to have even one "mediocre" day on this earth.  We deserve this pain and strife because we continually ask for it by our very sinful natures.  We see some sins as more horrendous than others, but in God's eyes - even the minor sins are detestable. Yes, we have to continue to fight against the gross injustices that are being committed around us.  But I think the best hope we can give those who are suffering in such situations (and ourselves) is to remember the brevity of this life and the hope that is offered to all of us for eternity - when we choose Him. An eternity that will be sin-free!  We can't even begin to imagine what that will be like because we can't have a single thought that is not tainted by sin in some way. But when we choose Him to save us from that sin, we will make it our mission to live out our faith (even we can't even fully understand it) in total trust that one day all these wrongs will be made right.  Justice will prevail - eventually.  We cannot correct all the wrongs of this world, and we become impatient with a God whom we know can fix it all in an instant. We wonder why He doesn't choose to do it NOW when we cannot imagine things getting worse than what we see on the news every day.  But in His sovereignty, He has chosen the day to judge.  And He tells us we are not privy to that information.  So, I must choose to trust Him - because of who He is - remembering who I am in comparison... I'm praying for your heartache and for the countless others who are hurting now, too - hoping to meet you in a joyful eternity!
Sep 29, 2011 11:38 AM Guest Christine  says in response to Andy:
Well said.              
Sep 29, 2011 11:59 AM Guest John  says in response to Jamie:
Interesting that humanists and others state "There are no absolutes." Absurd, because that statement is itself an Absolute. God is right, true, just, perfect, and above all, holy. Forever. Especially when we don't quite understand Him, which is all too often.
Sep 29, 2011 12:30 PM Guest Leah  says:
Thanks for encouraging us to be praying for Roger Ebert. What a sad and hopeless ideology he has. We pray that his eyes are opened to the truth and that he'd embrace it.
Sep 29, 2011 1:00 PM Guest Joe  says in response to Alta M.:

It is all in accordance with Gods will and while being that molested child, or grieving parent, or starving infant is absolutley horrifying, what is even worse is the thought of living an eternal life away from God. Terrible things happen all day every minute that this earth exists, a byproduct of living in a fallen world. Thankfully we have Jesus, and it has been made clear salvation comes through him and no one else. One day this life will cease to exist as we know it and whatever the end involves, I am confident it will be the most infinitely amazing experience we as believers could ever imagine. God knows every hair on our head, he has it under control.......his will be done!

And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose. For those God foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his son, that he might be the first born among many brothers and sisters.-Romans 8; 28-29 (NIV)

Sep 29, 2011 1:01 PM Guest Marilyn  says in response to deb:
Thanks for sharing the quote from your pastor.
Sep 29, 2011 1:15 PM Guest Gloria S.  says:

I think this is very sad for Mr. Ebert.  As I have always said, "I would rather believe and live my life as a Christian and die and find out it was not true, than to not believe and live my life as a non-believer and die and find out it is true."  God Bless Mr. Ebert and I pray for the Holy Spirit to soften his heart to believe.

Sep 29, 2011 3:11 PM Guest Diana  says in response to Trish:
Trish ~ Wow, your really hit the nail on the head with your description  of 'secular humanism'!  So VERY true.  Thanks for your comments and insight.
Sep 29, 2011 3:39 PM Guest Steven D  says in response to Alta M.:

Take a piece of paper and make two columns.  On the left column title it, "The Law of Sin and Death" and on the other title it, "The Law of the Spirit of Life in Christ Jesus."  Then under each heading list all the things that came into the world, or into a person for that matter, when that law is acted upon.

 

Disease, calamity, earthquakes, divorce, molestation, depression, etc. would obviously be under the first column, and joy, peace, health, prosperity, tenderness, self-control, kindness, etc. would be under the other.  Satan is the bringer of the first (through Adam) and Jesus is the bringer of the second.

 

Very simple, and this one chart alone will straighten out all theology.

 

Satan is bad, Jesus is good.  End of story.

 

John 10:10

Sep 29, 2011 5:51 PM Guest Scott  says in response to Dale W.:
Dale W., let me ask you respectfully:  Is it true that there is no such thing as truth?
Sep 29, 2011 6:53 PM Guest michelle c.  says in response to Alta M.:

alta m, go back to Genesis and remember God placed adam and eve in eden. there was only one tree they could not eat from, giving them free will. after eating from the tree God kicked them out of the garden. if they would have stayed in the garden they would have died (as God promised if they were disobedient) and spent eternity in hell. God sent his son jesus to redeem mankind and allow them to have everlasting life. God continues to give us free will as to whether we reject or accept him. this is why our only hope is in jesus christ.

God must judge all sin because he is holy. if he killed all the people so they could do no harm, he would have to judge all sin and sinners. God sees sin as evil no matter how large or small. this is precisely why many do not believe because they do not see their sin through the eyes of a holy God. we often ask jesus why he allows suffering. he ask us the same thing. ask yourself what am i doing to ease the suffering of others? you mention some specific things. are you actively doing something to ease the suffering in this world. jesus offers hope. hope that through suffering christians will act to help others and be salt and light. God indeed gives us free wil and has thus far beeen merciful enough to offer us hope and salvation. everything good we have comes from God, and remember he will judge evil in the world when he comes again.in ecclesaistes the writer concluded the meaning of life is a right relationship with God.

Sep 29, 2011 7:44 PM Guest John D.  says:
Everyone has their opinion, but it illustrates a good point. If you dabble in philosophy or any sciences that lift man up as the ultimate authority, then mankind is God. You will never arrive at the truth that God is God & our wisdom is foolishness, because men & women are your supreme beings or demi gods to be worshipped & adored. Wake up, sweet dreamers, we are sinners-compared to God & He wants to live with us-that's why we need a Savior who is God-Jesus our High Priest in Heaven!
Sep 30, 2011 6:12 AM Guest hat  says in response to Alta M.:
I don't think that suffering and pain in the world is redemptive.  That is to misread scripture.  In fact, not even the suffering and pain of a Christian martyr is redemptive.  Redemption comes through Christ alone.  Suffering and pain is the result of sin  And it is not necessarily or perhaps even usually the result of the sin of the one suffering.  God created man (humankind) to rule the earth and subdue it.  He then gave man free will and the ability to fulfill his destiny or to not.  Man (human kind) has for the most part abdicated the role of steward of  the creation to become servants of it--and have perverted the intended  purpose.  God allows this because anything else would make us puppets.  When man chose to eat of the tree of the knowledge of Good and Evil, he was in effect asking to know evil intimately--because he already knew good (God).  God granted that wish (not because it was His will that we know evil, but because He had given man free will).  All of us are suffering under the consequences of sin -- our own sin, the sins of others, generational sins.
Sep 30, 2011 6:37 AM Guest ZigZag63  says:
It is such an empty, hopeless feeling to believe that after death--there is nothing.  I believe that many individuals use this as an excuse to convince themselves that they needn't worry about their behavior/actions on earth.  If there is nothing, then there is no reason to live a good life, to help others and to love one another as God has--no responsibility, no accountability--no consequences--no judgement.  To live with this belief (or non-belief) gives no purpose to our lives or to our connection to each other.  It certainly makes life seem absolutely meaningless.  I don't think Mr. Ebert would write a book if he thought that his life was meaningless.  
Sep 30, 2011 6:48 AM Guest j3player  says:

Psalm 14:1-3 The fool says in his heart, "There is no God." They are corrupt,  they do abominable deeds, there is none that does good. The LORD looks down from  heaven upon the children of men, to see if there are any that act wisely, that  seek after God. They have all gone astray, they are all alike corrupt; there is  none that does good, no, not one.

Sep 30, 2011 7:41 AM Guest gbrc  says in response to hat:

"I don't think that suffering and pain in the world is redemptive.  That is to misread scripture.  In fact, not even the suffering and pain of a Christian martyr is redemptive.  Redemption comes through Christ alone."

 

Yes, hat, the Lord's passion and death brought about the redemption of the world; however, our sufferings when joined to the sufferings of Christ also bring about the salvation of the world.

 

"Now I rejoice in what I am suffering for you, and I fill up in my flesh what is still lacking in regard to Christ’s afflictions, for the sake of his body, which is the church."  Colossians 1:24 (NIV)

 

It's not that Christ's salvific act was somehow incomplete; rather, He permits and invites us to participate in and add to His redemptive work.  What a privilege! 

 

Before Christ, you are correct: suffering was not redemptive and had absolutely no meaning or purpose.  Now, through Him, our suffering becomes holy, powerful and has a very efficacious purpose and meaning.  That's why he exhorts us to "take up [our] cross daily and follow [Him]."  It's not a punishment to take up our cross -- again, it's a privilege.  We are to embrace it.

Sep 30, 2011 7:42 AM Guest J3player  says in response to Alta M.:

There is sin and evil in the world. Sin and evil is a result of the one who turned against God by wanting to replace God. There is good in world through Jesus.  If the world accepted Jesus as Lord and Savior and lived according to His teachings through faith then sin and evil would be eradicated over night. You must be born again to understand these teachings of God.      

2 Chronicles 7:14 (New International Version)14 if my people, who are called by my name, will humble themselves and pray and seek my face and turn from their wicked ways, then I will hear from heaven, and I will forgive their sin and will heal their land.

 

Read the book of Job.

Sep 30, 2011 7:53 AM Guest Charlie  says:
Let us also pray for those who are influenced away from God by Mr. Ebert's message.
Sep 30, 2011 8:18 AM Guest Dr. Dale S.  says in response to Charlie :

This could be said to be a matematical problem, and the best equation I have ever seen:

 

1 cross + 3 nails = 4 given

Sep 30, 2011 8:08 AM Guest Gariocho  says in response to Daren R.:
Mr. Ebert is logically and socially clever but spiritually empty. His foray into the porn industry forever clouded his moral judgement. God still cares about you, Roger. He is the ultimate producer-director. He is checking your dailies. Talk to Him now while you're still in production. When it's done there won't be retakes or remakes. No post production.
Sep 30, 2011 9:24 AM Guest David H.  says:
If you do not believe in God of the Bible, I dare you to read a little book called "The Prayer of Jabez".  Even if you have accepted Christ into you heart, you too can experience what he has experienced in his walk with the Lord, as I have.  Your relationship with the God of this universe will be beyond your imagination.    
Oct 3, 2011 11:23 AM Guest Iselande  says:

Jesus hmself did not pray for the whole world but rather for the sheep.  Why should I join you in prayer to pray for Roger Ebert? Please go back to basics.  Examples like Paulof Tarsus, The Eunich in that charriot were searching.  Read Romans. I live wit an agnostic mother who we have been trying to bring to church she reuses,we told her about Christ she isn't interested, se confessed with her mouth "God has done wonders formy life"  sure because she is a recipient of the great changes that took place in my life.  I despise my mother, I pity her and most of the time I can't stand her.  However, I practice Ephysians 1:6 I took her from a nursing home where her favorite sn placed her, give her a room n my house, feed her and give her daily medications. All because I love, fear and obey the LORD.  Thank you, Jesus ordered me to Honor her I don't have to display any human fickle display of love.  My love for her comes from the basis of Grace.  Through all the goodness of God towards my mother she has not budge she is he same manipulator, selfish,lazy oma I have known.  Se is well aware the only reason she is not on the street is becuse God ordered me to take her in.  Now,why me? I could ask.  Why I ave not Exprience the love of a mother? Romans 8:28.  I have learned to depend on God and This woman ha taught me how to be loving mother especially to my 2 girls and my son. Mine favored her boys. one is a pervert, the other a looser.  I grew up catholic God knows I became vere disenchanted with the church but not with My Wonderful Lord.  I prayed daily that all my 3 kids will serve and love the Lord all the days of their lives.  Christians need to learn to stop begging people to pray for those rebels who affirmed that they do no need God nor searching for him. Take care of the sheep who discouraged, those of us who are lukewarm and cold because of busyness of life, because of all the mrals decays in and out of the church. Pray for God to revive His Elect to stand fr the truth even when who are no longr popular.  Paul did...I did

When I became converted and met the Lord personally in a small bedroom in 1991 I was just like Roger Ebert the big difference was I heard the voice and people were praying for me.  Prayers were answered according to God's will and His sovereign Election before the foundation of the world.  I was desperate to know Him because I was young (25) empty and bare. I have never read anyone dragged kicking and screaming in the old or new testament to serve God.  If indeed Jesus died for the whole world.  What do we say about those are dead with the knowledge of Christ but yet refused Him?  On the Cross, Jesus did not beg for the 2 thieves to believe in Him, but yet one repented and believed seconds before death.  About the other sinner/rebel?  He cursed Jesus before dying. Stop asking Christians to pay for those rebellious and ungodly rebels. Pray for us who have to face the same individuals and reprobates.  Pray for us so we can stand the wiles and tricks of the devil.  Pray for us so we will be firm and not embrace the perversities of this new world that even Pastors are promoting. Pray the the remnants so we will stand even facing death not to be cowards.  Pray for us so we can shine so we may have  revival in this Country oce again.

Sep 30, 2011 2:24 PM Guest Cliff T.  says:
My one question to him is "What if you are wrong/"
Sep 30, 2011 5:13 PM Guest Pat  says:
"What profit a man if he gains the whole world and loses his soul" - Matthew 16.26   So sad to know that someone who has gained fame and fortune in this life will never be able to experience "the good life" in the next! Let's pray for him as the Body of Believers. There is still life - there is still HOPE! 
Sep 30, 2011 5:18 PM Guest Lisa V.  says:
Our God is so patient in trying to bring each and everyone of us into relationship with him...just give it a try!!!!
Oct 1, 2011 5:15 AM Guest C.J.  says:
Who knows what circumstances in life takes a man down the path of unbelief.  But for God's grace, there be I.  God is the one who can apprehend Mr. Ebert.  I will pray for him that he should not have to suffer the eternal pain of Hell.  If I were in his place I would hope that someone would pray for me as well.  "With man this is impossible, but with God all things are possible."  Thank You, LORD Jesus for dying for Roger Ebert and us all.  Your love overcomes!  Your sacrifice for all is sufficient.  The work of the Cross is finished-complete!  Amen!
Oct 1, 2011 8:42 PM Guest Barb  says:
Thanks for giving us the opportunity to pray for Mr. Ebert, a talented man to be sure.  Lord, Jesus, please do reveal yourself to him, one of Your children.  Go get Him with your love. 
Oct 2, 2011 2:31 AM Guest frank  says in response to Tina W.:

You are absolutely right that Jesus did not come to condemn the world -- it says so in the gospel of John, after all!  One might remember his admonition to the woman caught in adultery: "Neither do I condemn you."

 

Jesus came to save, not to condemn.  But the scriptures also say that those who do not believe are condemned already.  Jesus himself repeatedly warned about hell, about the consequences of rejecting God's provision for our sin.  Was he kidding?  Was he misinformed?

 

I don't believe Hell is a torture chamber, nor that all the passages are meant literally (Gehenna, for instance, was a garbage dump outside Jerusalem).  But it is very clear that Jesus thought it was a real place, and a place to be avoided.

Oct 3, 2011 10:58 AM Guest Renee  says:
Thank you for your review. I was going to get the book for a friend who is an entertainer and doesn't know the Lord. Now I will find another book to give this friend.  With out Christ we are blind to our tomorrows.  I pray for his eyes and soul to be opened to the Redeemer.
Oct 6, 2011 3:50 PM Guest Will  says:
I struggle with not wanting to live forever, either.  What's hard is that I do know there's a God.  He wants things for me that I don't even want for myself.  I still don't know how He's ever "used" me, or why Christians want to be "used."  The other day, my brother and his pregnant girlfriend were laughing about a movie they saw, which mocked religion.  Apparently, someone was asked about Santa Claus being real (which, if you mean the former Bishop of Myra, he is a historical figure), and then an unfair analogy was made about how people are silly to believe in a God who hears billions of prayers all at once.  So, at least I was able to add that (saying the question put human limits on God), and my brother said it was a good point.  The question itself is flawed.  How do we even know that billions of people pray?  It's sad, but probably a much lower number.  Out of the billions of prayers, how many are to YHWH, who can actually hear them and has the authority to take action?  The timing aspect is irrelevant, since God doesn't operate on our timeline.
Oct 29, 2011 12:14 PM Guest John  says:
What a sad life without God.
Nov 7, 2011 11:13 AM Guest Gary  says in response to Dale W.:

Dear Dale,

 

You've venture into the same arena of error as Pilat did when he ignored JESUS' explanation of Truth. It caused Pilat to make messed up choices. Christ is The Truth. JESUS is "The Way, The Truth & The Life". No One goes to God The Father without JESUS as a mediator.

 

Gary

Actions