Thank you Jim! My children attend a Lutheran Day School and I wondered why the usual policy of 'free dress' on special days (Super Bowl, Valentine's Day, Christmas) was turned down for St Patrick's Day (yep, they would wear the 'green'). Here we have in a young man an outstanding example of going to the 'Roman's' and teaching Christ's Resurrection and Redemption for those who would believe... In a pagan society, St Patrick must have endured formidable resistance yet persevered in proclaiming the gospel and bringing souls to Christ. Of all the days that Christian's could celebrate proudly alongside a secular theme (Valentine's Day), this would be the one to reclaim for its historicity and message of hope and servitude!
While the 'wearing of the green' has political division overtones; in America it traditionally represents 'Ireland' the Emerald Isle...with our great history of Irish immigrants, I think all Americans have a little bit of the Irish in them, blood or not...
Actually, Valentine's Day is ST. Valentine's Day. Another great saint in Christianity that we should at least have an idea about so that that day can be better celebrated as well!
(With an Northern Irish accent):
Aye, Jim lad, but can ye dance the jig?!
Éirinn go brách
Happy St. Pat's Day
God Bless
I couldn't disagree more. I don't think this logically could get carried out in a way in American culture that would not leave us shocked. What exactly would we superimpose from our American culture on the Cross and church practices? We're talking about pagan idolatry incorporated with Christianity. Isn't that syncretism?
We could change churches into sweat lodges. We could superimpose crystals, dollar bills, and footballs on the cross, so Americans would find worshipping God more natural. We'll call it the "American Cross". We could do a bit of “Tashlan” when it comes to Muslims. I think we could adulterate Christianity very nicely to make it more palatable to the natives.
To be fair, I'll have to consider Apostle Paul's appeal to Mars Hill using "to an unknown god', as a possible defense for this, but so far, I'm not seeing it.
"credibility"? What are we trying to prove to the world? That their incorrect beliefs actually are Scriptural? Or that we are like them, so that if we are a little more "American", they'll be a little more "Christian"?
I'm becoming more and more concerned about FotF.
IF YOU'RE CONFUSED, THEN SO AM I. I WAS THINKING THE EXACT SAME THING AS I READ THE ARTICLE.
AND I ALSO WONDERED IF THAT ISN'T PART OF THE REASON FOR THE RELIGIOUS STRIFE IN IRELAND.
Tracy,
your basic question is smart, it's always right to be cautious.
Here's one principle to apply: Paul said "all things are lawful for me, but all things are not expedient, all things are lawful for me, but not all things edify."
Did St. Patrick edify? With the virtue of hindsight, it's pretty fair to say that he did. The Irish christians were a great force for spiritual enlightenment throughout Europe, especially before the tragic schism in 1054 that separated the eastern and western branches of Christianity.
The tribal conflicts between Catholic and Protestant in Ireland aren't due to St. Patrick's use of religious symbolism, but due to a history of conflict between Britain and Ireland.
There is one correction needed: St. Patrick was born in SCOTLAND!! To say he was from "Britain" implies he was from England.
("Great Britain" is all of England, Scotand, Ireland and Wales combined.)
As someone of Scottish heritage, I was thrilled to learn that St. Patrick was actually a Scotsman who evangelized Ireland!
Ireland "claims" him, but so should Scotland! :-)
I agree, but before we get judgmental, we have to examine our own hearts. John Calvin said "all men are idol factories," and he was right. We have easter bunnies, egg hunts, Christmas trees, and all are traditional symbols of what some consider "real Christianity" but they bear no resemblance to the first century church. Images of Christ? the cross? they are all symbols. I understand Patrick's motivation to express Christianity in terms that the Irish would embrace; even though more enlightened Christians today might not practice that way. Or would we?
Remembering pioneers of the Faith for their contribution to it is not necessarily indicating approval of their methods.
Sola Scriptura...Sola Fide....Sola Gratia....Solo Christo...Soli Deo Gloria
My family LOVES the movie, "St. Patrick, the Irish Legend", starring Patrick Bergin, Malcolm McDowell, Alan Bates, and Susannah York. (Amazon.com carries this movie, as does Net Flicks.) It tells about many of the (true) miracles that God worked through St. Patrick; one of which is similar to Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednigo (the children thrown into the firey furnace in the Old Testament).
We've loaned our movie to various friends who have become great fans of St. Patrick too because of this movie. (It's a great movie!) (Please note: We fast forward through the "peasant massacre" when our 6-year-old is watching.)
Articles like this aid and abet this situation. God is Almighty, unapologetic, and DYNAMIC. His mercy is NOT divorced from the force of His Truth.
Be ye HOT or COLD or I will SPEW you out of My mouth! God.
We normally call this syncretism, the blending of various religious beliefs into a new religious form. This is why Ireland or Mexico can be almost entirely "Christian" with only a few who trust in Jesus for salvation. But there is something about a wonderful God who would save the Irish who trust His Son's death on the cross as sufficient payment for God to forgive them once and for all (Heb 10:8-12).
I'm not only Irish, but I was a Catholic and am now a Protestant. More study on St. Patrick is needed. The history of St. Patrick has been re-written by the Catholics. He was not only NOT Catholic, but was hunted by the Inquisitioners and it wasn't until he was dead and buried that the Catholic church adopted him and made him a saint. He did serve as a witness to the Irish to teach them about Jesus and his resurrection and he did promote literacy and wooed the Irish clans to see God and a loving and merciful God. You can't believe everything you read and the process of re-writing history continues to this day - just as those who have decided the holocaust didn't really happen. We need to be tolerant of other religions and we need to fight to preserve freedom of religion in this country. We also need to do our homework so that we learn lessons from the past and change the way we do things in the future.
*-